The following is a list of the top 10 baking sheets for your kitchen. To create this list, we decided to enlist the help and honest opinions of our friends, relatives, colleagues, or just about anybody who has loads of baking experience. Of course, we also sought the help of some professional bakers, whether they worked inside hotels, bakeshops or patisseries, or just ran home or online business where they sold their delicious baked goods.
The reason why we ended up making a compilation of the ten best baking sheets this year is that baking just so happens to be one of our biggest passions. We also received plenty of requests asking us to make this list, and of course, we were more than happy to oblige. You may also use this list as a guide in case you’re still trying to get the hang of baking, and want to know more about what the best baking sheets are for the job. And after doing loads of research and asking around, we now give you our list of the best baking sheets of 2021:
Best Baking Sheets Review Center
|#1 - Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Sheet||99%|
|#2 - Rachael Ray 47425 3-Piece Baking Sheets||96%|
|#3 - Wilton Recipe Right 3-Piece Cookie Pan||95%|
|#4 - Baker’s Secret Cookie/Baking Sheet||92%|
|#5 - Calphalon Nonstick 2-Piece Baking Sheets||90%|
|#6 - Circulon Non-Stick Baking Sheet||88%|
|#7 - Good Cook 3-Piece Nonstick Cookie Sheet||86%|
|#8 - Farberware 3-Piece Nonstick Baking Sheets||85%|
|#9 - Chicago Metallic Nonstick Baking Sheet||82%|
|#10 - T-Fal 3-Piece Airbake Ultra Cookie Sheet||80%|
It’s bound to be quite simple to identify the most suitable set of baking sheets for your needs, so let’s begin:
#1 – Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Sheet
Not only are Nordicware’s products top-notch, but they are also durable as well. Their baking sheets ensure that you will receive nothing but lifetime strength, versatility, and durability. And it has also been proven time and again that these sheets never rust.
Apart from the fact that the sheets are composed of high-grade Aluminum, it’s also got great conductivity too. This means that the sheets work fine when you place them in a convection oven or an electric oven. And finally, the Aluminum found in the sheets is mixed together with some bits of encapsulated steel, to stop it from warping too much.
This baking sheet is made in the USA. You can be certain that your baked goods will all rise and bake evenly, because of the heat conductivity brought about by the product’s aluminum base. It’s also got an encapsulated steel rim, which stops it from warping.
What We Like About It:
These were one of the best baking sheets that our tester has ever tried. He has spent dozens and dozens of hours online, trying to find which baking sheet was the best for him and his baking business — Apparently, he was fed up with wasting too much time and money trying to perfect his southern-style buttermilk biscuits, just to find out that the bottom halves are all burned to a crisp.
Nordicware’s set of baking sheets served him well, and have never failed him in his baking. He liked it so much that he ended up purchasing two more for his friends and family members. The dimensions of the sheet were all perfect, so he was able to stack them together with his other baking sheets.
#2 – Rachael Ray 47425 3-Piece Baking Sheets
The baking sheet in this five-piece bakeware collection is very durable. It is comprised of a high-quality set of baking sheets, all of which are made to provide you with the best products and baked goods.
There are three types of baking sheets in various sizes (Small, medium, large). All of the sheets are also constructed from strong carbon material, which is not just very durable but won’t warp after too much use. And they’re very easy to clean as well.
The sheets are coated with a nonstick material, which gives off great food release. The sizes of the pans are the following: 9 x 13 inches (small) 10 x 15 inches (medium) and 11 x 17 inches (large).
A standout feature that this sheet has over the rest is the handles. They provide you with a wide grip and come in different hues. They can also withstand heat measuring up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit/260 degrees Celsius.
What We Like About It:
These pans have a slick and nice feel to them — They weren’t thick enough, but not thin either. They also have a rather aesthetically-pleasing look and feel to them. So far, our tester hasn’t used it too much for her baking needs, but every time she does, it hasn’t failed her at all.
The size options are just right for all of her baking and cooking needs. She can also stack them up inside each other, so they won’t occupy too much space inside her kitchen cabinets or drawers. The nonstick coating on the pans was also great, and she never really had to wash them that much after cooking food in it.
#3 – Wilton Recipe Right 3-Piece Cookie Pan
Just like their other products, Wilton’s own set of baking sheets are designed to give you evenly-baked cookies for you and your family. The product comes with its own set of convenient handles, which you can easily use for handling and gripping. It is also made from a type of underlying material, so it is easy to clean.
The sheets are coated with a type of nonstick material. Not only does this particular set of baking sheets enjoy immense popularity because of the brand, but it’s also comprised of heavy-duty material, and gives you perfectly baked goods after you put them out of the oven.
What We Like About It:
We just so happened to own this exact baking sheet, and it has worked well for us. However, since purchasing, it has started to look grungy. So we ended up buying another set in the end.
There are comments from other users who say that this particular baking sheet is prone to warping, but so far, it hasn’t happened with our own. We were always ready to spend more cash on higher-quality baking sheets, but because this one garnered so many high reviews from our testers, perhaps this one wasn’t so bad.
#4 – Baker’s Secret Cookie/Baking Sheet
This is perhaps the secret to amazing cookies, and one of the best choices that you can have for great baking sheets. Not only does it work excellently, but it also comes at a very affordable price!
The sheet comes with an enhanced wax coating, which ensures that nothing you prepare ends up sticking to it once it’s been baked. The sheets also come with contoured handles that you can hold on to. The handles remain cool even while you store them in the oven.
The baking sheets are also dishwasher-safe and can be cleaned easily. Aside from that, it is also very durable and can withstand abuse in comparison to other baking sheets on the list.
This baking sheet is perfect if you’re not really into baking pastries, and want to go for fat-free meals instead. Baker’s Secret Cookie Sheet is small enough for you to bake up to six cookies to feed your kids or your friends. The sheet itself is composed of 0.5-gauge steel. Its durability ensures that you can use it alongside metal spatulas and other cooking utensils. And not only is it lightweight, but it is also pretty durable and easy-to-clean as well.
What We Like About It:
This was a highly-recommended baking sheet and has often appeared in so many lists from culinary publications. Often, these publications would recommend the Bakers’ Secret Cookie Sheet as a cheaper alternative to a more expensive counterpart.
It arrived at our tester’s doorstep looking clean, and with a decent size. It was also thin and lightweight and surprisingly durable enough for a baking sheet. While she used the sheet to bake gingersnaps, the reason for the product’s low price started dawning on her. The nonstick material that coated the sheet didn’t stay on for too long. Nope, it did not peel off — Instead, it got stickier with each use, and left a nasty residue.
Another downside was that it left grease stains and marked easily. If this is a metal-based pan, you can easily scrub it off with the aid of a wire brush — However, with this particular baking sheet, it was close to impossible.
#5 – Calphalon Nonstick 2-Piece Baking Sheets
This particular baking sheet comes in two variants: And both of these sheets contain interlocking layers, allowing them to release your baked goods much faster, as well as to stay dishwasher-safe. A popular opinion that people have regarding these particular baking sheets was that they worked two times better than other brands on the market, thanks to their durability.
The sheets are excellent for baking, one-sheet dinners, jelly rolls, as well as for baking cookies and brownies. But they’re not just for delicious baked goods — You can also use them to make things such as one-sheet pan meals, and roasted meat or veggies. You can even use this product as a way to reheat leftovers.
The product is also composed of a durable type of steel core, which heats evenly, so your food is released from the oven perfectly browned. It can withstand a high amount of heat, which won’t cause it to warp. The interior also contains interlocking nonstick layers. These layers are made to bring you a high-performance, long-lasting release. The sheets have a measurement of 12 x 17 inches.
What We Like About It:
Some of the first things we noticed about this product are its raised edges — Our tester says that the company added this feature as a way to prevent spills. Brownie pans are just the excellent size to fit into these baking sheets, in case you’re in the mood to make some gooey fudgy brownies or blondies. It is also dishwasher safe.
One of the best things about Calphalon’s Nonsticking Baking Sheets is that you don’t have to worry about oiling your pan or using parchment paper, and food comes off very easily without it.
Calphalon’s own set of bakeware ensures that you’ll be able to cook your food with ease. The function and quality of these sheets were just excellent. Silicone mats also fit nicely with these baking sheets. An interesting feature here was that they warped a bit while they were stored in the oven, but flattened eventually as they cooled down.
The sheets were also quite easy to clean, but the issue here was that they were a tad bit big to fit into enclosed spaces with the tester’s other baking sheets. And despite the fact that these were confirmed to be dishwasher-safe, our tester suggested that we wash these sheets by hand instead, in the sink.
#6 – Circulon Nonstick Baking Sheet
Considered to be one of the best baking sheets on the market today, this product is made up of three baking sheets, all of which utilize a food release system. This system ensures that there aren’t any food particles stuck to the surface after you’re done cooking.
It also has a cooking and heating ability that you won’t find on other baking sheets — This ensures that your cookies all come out in the perfect shape. It’s a very sturdy and durable set of baking sheets, plus the surface is very easy to clean up, too.
With the Circulon Nonstick Cookie Pan, even your basic biscotti and raspberry shortbread cookies will easily slide off and not stick to the product. Everything that you make using these sheets will all come out beautifully and tasting pretty good.
What We Like About It:
The tester for this product has been spending too much cash for years, trying to find great baking sheets. After buying one from an expensive shop, it becomes tarnished, leaves nasty stains, and just looks horrible all in all — Leaving her very frustrated.
To her surprise, every dish that she had cooked with the Circulon Nonstick Cookie Pan has turned out great and didn’t stick to the sheet at all. However, because the sheet is made from a type of dark metal, she had to change her baking time from the usual ten minutes to fifteen. She has since used this product to toast bits of garlic for pasta, to broil a rib-eye steak for dinner.
There are so many great things to be said about Circulon Nonstick Cookie Pan- They are 100% nonstick, so meat, roasted veggies, biscuits, and cookies all come off with ease. Since nothing sticks, they are very easy to clean- You do not need to be skeptical, the claims of easy cleaning are true! Since they are solid and heavy, they do not warp in the oven.
#7 – Good Cook 3-Piece Nonstick Cookie Sheet
Go right ahead and bake tasty treats that you can easily slide off the tray with Good Cook’s nonstick cookie sheet. The whole package is comprised of three pieces of baking sheets, each carrying a different size. This lets you pick the correct sheet anytime for your baked goods.
Just because the sizes are different doesn’t mean it’ll affect the quality of your food — Every one of them is meant to provide you with a great performance. All three sheets are covered in the nonstick coating, letting you prepare greasy food without the risk of staining them with oil.
Your food will bake with ease, and you won’t even have to scrub that hard when you clean the sheets. Two baking sheets will build up a layer of air, so your food will bake evenly — No more undercooked fish or brownies! Good Cook’s sheets will provide you with pure versatility in regards to cooking. The sheets are also dishwasher-safe, which is a definite property that all baking sheets should have.
What We Like About It:
This set of baking sheets was pretty decent — But unfortunately, not the best. After a couple of uses, our tester’s own set of sheets did warp a little bit. According to him, a helpful tip here is to lie it flat before placing it in the oven and manually drying it instead, instead of chucking it in the dishwasher. Our tester’s baking sheets started developing rust, which is never a good sign. Be sure to keep it well-maintained, since this is a low-quality set.
Other than that, it worked pretty well — He has baked oatmeal cookies and store-bought pizzas on them, and they came out edible and nicely toasted. But then again, they had minimum expectations for this product. They even gave off a loud pop a few minutes after he placed them in the oven, and it turns out that they were warping.
#8 – Farberware 3-Piece Nonstick Baking Sheets
Similar to another entry on this list, the Farberware nonstick bakeware cookie pan contains three sheets in one, all carrying different sizes. It is crafted from high-quality material that not only ensures the right and even amount of baking and heating but also follows the company’s own set of Quality Assurance Standards.
The sheets come in a lovely light-gray hue, and this makes it easy for you to spot if a part of your food, or if an individual cookie has browned or crisped up too much. Overall, these baking sheets come with excellent construction. This is a sign that it is made out of the best quality materials.
Apart from baked goods, it can also handle cooking meals like fish or chicken. It’s a type of baking sheet which performs perfectly, and can be cleaned easily — And let’s not forget that Farberware itself is a reputable brand.
It’s got nonstick material on both the inside and outside of the sheet, so the food can slide off quickly, and clean up only takes seconds.
What We Like About It:
The price was a little bit too steep for our tester, but it was all worth it. The product’s nonstick qualities were the main highlight. But of course, she had to keep it well-maintained in order to preserve its quality. There is a list of warnings if you want to keep it nonstick- Never use nonstick sprays, don’t clean it with strong chemicals, don’t use abrasive cleaners, or place it in the dishwasher. Also, different sizes allowed her to cater to different foods and quantities.
Her Snicker-doodle cookies didn’t slide off the tray after the first use, but one of her immediate concerns here was that she wouldn’t be able to cook certain dishes on the sheets and that the food would come right off and taste undercooked after the product begins warping. But her main concern here was the price.
#9 – Chicago Metallic Nonstick Baking Sheet
The Chicago Metallic nonstick jelly roll pan baking sheet is perfect for handling all sorts of cookies, as well as other baked goods and meals. It’s a baking sheet that specializes in consistent heat distribution due to the fact that it’s made from carbon steel. It’s also very heavy and durable.
The sheet comes in various sizes, so it can fit all types of ovens. And what’s more, the product also contains a nonstick surface, making it easy for you to clean and wipe things away.
The sheet is very thin, so it’s easy to store in cabinets — Or you can just stack them with your other array of baking sheets. This makes it a great option for you if you want to save some space. Another advantage here is that it’s dishwasher-safe, which is a rarity in regards to good baking sheets.
This item is excellent, and can be used by both expert and novice bakers — After all, a sturdy baking sheet is an essential tool for the job.
What We Like About It:
We were huge fans of Chicago Metallic’s line of baking products, especially their baking sheets and jelly roll pans. Our tester was quite surprised that this brand was pretty much unheard of because she assumed that this would be very popular. She has used these baking sheets for just about anything — From crisping up bacon to add in pasta to baking sugar cookies.
There was a tendency for her to bake several foods on high heat, and the product didn’t even warp, thanks to the heavy gauge wire. And according to her, she does like to put her baking sheets through “extreme torture” — By tossing them in the oven literally, placing them in the dishwasher, or even using a metal spatula or knife in case a cookie won’t come off it. But despite all of that, the Chicago Metallic nonstick jelly roll baking sheets were still very strong. She assured us that this product would surely be worth the money.
#10 – T-Fal 3-Piece Airbake Ultra Cookie Sheet
This baking sheet is crafted from pure Aluminum. The aluminum finish guarantees that your cookies or whatever you’ve decided to bake won’t ever get burnt or at least too browned and crisp.
The same material also lessens the chance of rusting, which is a common issue in regards to utilizing cookie sheets. The sheet is also known for its outstanding durability. T-Fal ensures that you can easily wear your trusty chef’s hat, and prepare some yummy baked goods using their sheets.
T-Fal’s line of bakeware goods are always top-notch, so it’s not surprising that they are known to make ‘The Original Insulated Bakeware.’ It has been proven again and again that their baking goods always give out the best results.
What We Like About It:
The tester was a huge fan of T-Fal’s airbake line, so he decided to purchase these to trade in some older baking sheets that he owned. One of the bigger cons that these sheets had was that they scratched so easily, so he resorted to using silicone-based baking tools just to scrape them out of the pan.
A second tester claims that the sheets that she had used were fantastic, especially since they came in various sizes. They produced different results in comparison to the old version of the T-Fal AirBake that she owned, due to the small round indents found on the back (For even baking). She used them to bake fish sticks, and the result made crispy edges.
There is nothing more disheartening for a baker than seeing grimy baking sheets. Yes, you can still use them, but they will lack the appeal that a brand-new baking sheet carries. Hopefully, this list was able to help you out in picking a great baking sheet to use this year — So you won’t have to suffer through underbaked, burned, or stuck cookies to the pan. Invest, and buy one that is sure to do the right job.
Factors to Consider When Buying Best Baking Sheets
This is the key feature that you need to pay attention to, as each one can have a different effect on the outcome of your baked goods. A dark-colored surface on the bakeware will cause the food to be brown more easily because it absorbs the heat of the oven. Aluminum is a good material for bakeware because it’s a good conductor of heat, which results in even baking, but the shiny surface of the Aluminum may prevent proper browning. Nonstick bakeware consists of steel or Aluminum, which has a nonstick coating applied to it. This coating allows you to easily lift off the food from the surface of the bakeware. This also makes it quick and simple to clean;
The size of your baking sheet can make a whole difference for your result. Even though bigger ones are highly requested in the baking world, make sure it will fit your oven, as it happens quite often that the size does not fit into the small ovens. The solution is to buy a set of 2 baking sheets where you can even multi-task with your food. But if you need to bake some cookies and then some chicken afterward, then it would be best to separate them as they would soak up unwanted aromas and flavors;
Baking Pans vs. Cookie Sheets
Much deeper construction design is equipped into baking pans. Plus, there are often more options regarding sizes and shapes when it comes to baking pans. That’s because these designs are intended to minimize, if not entirely avoid spills. Cookie sheets, however, differ from baking sheets because of their bottoms, which are designed to be flat and do not have raised sides. This will help to make sure that the cookies you bake on them don’t lose their shape and that they bake evenly;
Care & Maintenance
This part is very important if you want to enjoy the maximum performance of your baking sheets. You need to use care methods according to the type of material it’s made out of, and also if it has a nonstick coating. This also means you need to take care of it in the same manner as other nonstick baking sheets. To take good care of bakeware that isn’t equipped with nonstick material for its surface, you’re advised to use hot or lukewarm water and liquid soap when washing it. Plus, it’s important not to use metal utensils or knives on the nonstick surface. You wouldn’t want to scratch its surface, right? Also, before putting them in the dishwasher, remember to check if your baking sheets are dishwasher safe as it can cause unnecessary damage. Follow these steps to make sure no harmful chemical, plastic or toxic material will come in contact with your food;
If you want to avoid ending up with warped baking sheets, then be sure to find one that will suit your needs. If you’re going to use very high temperatures, then stainless steel baking sheets are what you need to look for. It’s solid and doesn’t warp in the oven. If you are looking for something intermediate or basic, then Aluminum is also a great choice for you. It’s an extremely low cost and has great thermal properties. This is also the most popular choice at the moment;
Rimmed or Not Rimmed
Having a rim on your baking sheet prevents cookies placed around the edge not to bake evenly. Non-rimmed allows heat to reach all every single cookie consistently. So keep this in mind when you go through our collection of the top 10 baking sheets this year;
If you want a more pleasant baking experience, then this feature is a lifesaver. Once your goods are cooked, they can be easily removed and served. Plus, cleaning it will not be a big fuss;
If you’re planning to do a lot of baking, then you’re advised to buy some of the mixed sets in our selection. This is to cover all your baking needs. Yes, it costs more money, but in the end, it’s generally cheaper. This means you’ll save money by buying mixed sets, instead of purchasing them separately;
Having baking sheets equipped with dishwasher-safe features makes cleaning easier. This can save you a lot of time and energy. However, there’s a downside when it comes to washing them in a dishwasher. That’s because they’re more likely to wear down very quickly; and
Warranty & Price
Products like these come with a warranty. You’re recommended to pay attention to this aspect. Generally, a product’s warranty is a testament to a manufacturer’s trust and confidence in the overall durability and performance of their products. Under this warranty, they’ll often replace any bakeware that has defects relating to its build materials, coating, and construction. Unusual wear and tear, along with damages due to misuse, aren’t included in the warranties of most products (not just bakeware). So be extra careful in reading usage instructions.
These are the most essential factors that you should always consider before buying the best product from our roundup of the ten best baking sheets this 2021. This is likely to make your baking adventures special. We wish you a lot of success with your delicious baked goods!
How We Chose The Best Baking Sheets?
First, we checked out widely used online shopping platforms, primarily Amazon’s best-seller list for this category. Since many of our fellow bakers use this platform and recommend it, we took notes of their experience in using a variety of baking sheets. Our goal is to help you find the most suitable bakeware for all your upcoming delicious goods.
Second, we showed our shortlist of the best products to our friends, relatives, and colleagues to gather information about their thoughts and experience. It was no surprise that everyone had something to share since they all used baking sheets at some point, and most of them still do.
Third, in the sea of offers for baking sheets in the market today, we carefully studied the reviews and ratings by other buyers in Amazon and other online shopping platforms. When it comes to these reviews, both positive and negative comments have been included in our research, so that you can find the best fit for you. This allowed us to take notes of the key benefits and advantages of each product in our shortlist. We came across many different opinions and experiences which vary from price, quality, and quantity, which we’ll gladly share with you.
Fourth, we used all the data that we managed to collect for shortening our list of the top 10 baking sheets this 2021. Also, we formulated testing guidelines and evaluation systems using the same data.
In addition, we formed a team of testers with a combination of home bakers, pro chefs, foodies, and kitchen lovers with a variety of skills and experience. This is so that no matter what level you’re at, you’ll likely to quickly and easily find the best one for your exact needs. This means it doesn’t matter if you’re a beginner, intermediate, or an expert baker — There’s bound to be information that’s interesting enough for you to learn something new.
Fifth, after asking this team to test each of the products in our selection of the best ten baking sheets in 2021, we carefully took note of their test results. Then, we deployed our evaluation process.
With all this data, we managed to provide the comprehensive details for each of the products in our roundup of the ten best baking sheets this 2021. We covered all essentials, from extensive research, thorough testing, and unbiased evaluation procedures that are quick and easy to absorb.
Do You Need Baking Sheets?
Of course, you do — Baking sheets are a highly essential part of baking delicious pastries and bread. Without the aid of a baking sheet, your baked goods will either stick onto the baking tray, burn to a crisp, or leave a hard-to-remove residue when you take them out of the oven.
There’s nothing like pulling out a hot baking sheet full of delicious cookies, straight from the oven. But the experience is ruined when your cookies don’t turn out quite how you imagined. Baking perfect goods is quite a challenging task. And the type of bakeware you use determines the success or failure of a recipe. When you find the right one, you’re likely to create nothing but delicious memories.
Everyone who has tried out baking, even something simple as a batch of classic chocolate chip cookies, will tell you that this job will only require nothing but the best ingredients. Also though professionals make it look so easy, baking is no walk in the park, unless you have all of the right materials for the job. And we’re not just talking about ingredients — We also mean the tools and utensils. Choosing the right tools for baking is a priority that will make your goods the best they can be.
Baking sheets — Also known as cookie sheets — Are essential when you want to bake. If you’re going to bake some fantastic cookies or cupcakes, then the baking sheets mentioned in our collection of the top 10 products today are perhaps the best and most viable option, especially since they’re not too expensive. And once you get that new baking sheet, the real question is: What type of cookies are you going to make first?