The 10 Best Canned Tomatoes (2022)

Perfect ripe tomatoes are not always available. But that does not mean one should not have tomatoes in their place. They also constitute a part of a healthy diet. Depending on season and location, sometimes ripe tomatoes are tricky, especially the Italian ones. They not only go well with salads but are also an essential ingredient in the preparation of the sauce.

Best Canned TomatoesThere are several ways to preserve tomatoes and ship them to various parts of the world. Canned tomatoes are prepared in several ways, such as whole tomatoes by peeling off their skin, diced tomatoes, or crushed tomatoes. These forms are kitchen-ready and stay fresh. Moreover, the various tomato brands pack the best Italian tomatoes. Enlisted below is the list of brands that serve the best-canned tomatoes.

Best Canned Tomatoes Comparison & Rating

Now that you’ve seen our top 10 recommendations, we’ll give you more detail on each of them, including why we liked them. When you’re ready, click the yellow button to get the best price on Amazon!

1. Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes

Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled Tomatoes Product Image

Cento San Marzano Organic Peeled tomato is probably the best brand of San Marzano tomatoes. The company has a production plant in the San Marzano region of Italy. The region is known for its fertile soil and climate, which is very suitable for growing the best Italian tomatoes of its kind. The plant’s location is very near to the local farmer’s market. This enables the swift delivery of the handpicked best San Marzano tomatoes to the process plant within a few hours. This ensures that the tomatoes stay fresh when they reach the plant before peeling off and packing in a can.

Cento San Marzano specializes in packing high-quality plum tomatoes. The tomatoes have a rich texture added with natural preservatives, and they are delicious. The Natural additive is a raw juice derived from fresh Basil leaves. The Can also contain basil leaves. Other than that, no other additives, preservatives, or colors are used.

The flavor of these Italian canned tomatoes is incredible and has a thick puree. The puree imparts natural color to the tomatoes and results in a thick sauce. The brand is famous and serves premium quality products that are purely organic and great for health. The Cento San Marzano brand of canned tomatoes usually has whole tomatoes with their skins peeled off with organic ingredients like organic salt and natural citric acid.

What we like about it:

Cento San Marzano organic serves one of the best-canned tomatoes on the internet. The rich plum and whole tomatoes are packed into an ergonomic, easy-to-open can. The tomatoes are freshly handpicked from the farm of San Marzano and contain no fat, which helps them add to the healthy diet plan. Also, the whole tomatoes can be crushed or diced to prepare a thick sauce that you can serve with French fries, pizza, or pasta.

Check Price on Amazon


2. Carmelina Marzano Italian Peeled Tomatoes

Carmelina San Marzano Italian Whole Peeled Tomatoes Product Image

While talking of the best canned San Marzano tomatoes, Carmelina is a unique brand. Carmelina e’… San Marzano has earned its name in the list of canned tomato brands through its high-quality whole tomatoes. The brand is a San Marzano canned tomatoes brand. This implies that this brand uses tomatoes are specially imported from the Campania region, Italy. Campania of Italy has fertile soil with a suitable climate and moderate temperature, perfect for growing the best Italian tomatoes.

Carmelina is considered to produce the best canned whole tomatoes, which you can use for versatile purposes. The san Marzano tomatoes undergo a set of processes involving steam peeling, adding natural ingredients, and packing in a can with their in-house prepared succulent puree. The canned tomatoes also do not contain any salt, citric acid, calcium chloride, or any other artificial preservatives. The tomatoes are gluten-free, and no artificial flavors policies make Carmelina one recognized canned tomato brand.

If you want to make lasagna or spaghetti, Carmelina canned tomatoes also serve modestly in the preparation of sauce, which tastes delicious. You can also use the puree to make pizza which enhances the taste of the pizza. The Italian peeled tomatoes can also make pasta sauce, which is easy and less time-consuming to make.

What we like about it:

Carmelina provides the best Italian canned tomatoes, which you can versatilely use. It is ready to eat as well as it can be cooked in a microwave or can be used to prepare sauces for various dishes. The canned tomatoes and the puree have a rich taste that sticks to the taste buds, and the price is quite reasonable. So if you are looking for the best-canned tomatoes for sauce, the product is right in front of you, which makes your dish delicious and makes you an incredible cook.

Check Price on Amazon


3. Sclafani Whole Peeled Tomatoes

Sclafani Whole Peeled Tomatoes Product Image

Sauces are an essential part of any part. But most of the sauces have added preservatives with artificial color and, most importantly, less tomato. Thus, the Sclafani family brought in a healthy alternative labeled as best canned tomato sauce. The family began their business in the food industry in history in 1800. They initiated a small grocery store in New York. They started importing Italian products, and now they are one of the finest and best brand canned tomatoes. Sclafani whole tomatoes are made from fresh ripe tomatoes, tomato juice, and salt grown near the packing facility in southern New Jersey.

Sclafani has been known for its quality over the years. And to maintain their quality, the tomatoes are handpicked from farms. This New Jersey brand eventually gives tough competition to the world’s best canned Italian tomatoes brands. And they have been able to do so because they select firm tomatoes, have no stringy core, and are not broken.

They are peeled, and the tomatoes are an excellent substitute for sauces. The whole tomatoes can be crushed and prepared into a rich taste and texture in a sauce. The sauce goes well with pasta and pizza. The Sclafani tomatoes taste sweeter and not acidic, and thus the canned tomatoes are less bitter than their competitors.

What we like about it:

Sclafani canned tomatoes may not be from Italy, but they are as good as the Italian tomatoes canned with natural ingredients like basil juice and puree. Moreover, this brand’s canned tomatoes are silky red with a mouthwatering flavor and rich aroma that makes these tomatoes suitable for making sauces for pasta and pizza. It is one of the best-canned tomatoes for pizza sauce and best-canned tomatoes for pasta sauce with significantly less water content and more pulp content.

Check Price on Amazon


4. Muir Glen Diced Tomatoes

Muir Glen Canned Tomatoes, Organic Diced Tomatoes Product Image

Nothing tastes better than diced tomatoes. They taste delicious and save time and equipment, and the effort to chop the tomatoes. Muir Glen does an excellent job of being the final-consumption product. Dice tomatoes are easy to serve and go well with lasagna or bruschetta. Best diced tomatoes are a ‘must add’ to the kitchen cart whenever available.

And Muir Gland sees the opportunity to provide the consumers with the diced canned tomatoes. With its state-of-the-art facility to grow organic tomatoes, chop them in slices, and pack them in an ergonomic, Muir Glen can make it one of the best canned diced tomatoes brands worldwide. Muir Glen organic tomatoes follow modern farming techniques to grow organic tomatoes in the San Joaquin Valley of California in the United States.

Muir Glen aims to be well certified by various standardized bodies in the food industry. The processes through which the diced tomatoes are brought into the market help the tomatoes stay fresh and retain their flavor and texture. The Can usually comes with a sea salt seasoning that adds more taste while making sauces.

What we like about it:             

The cans and the tomatoes are indigenous to California, and it takes only 8 hours for the tomatoes to process from farms to cans. They are stored in organic cans that help them retain the rich flavor of the organic tomatoes. The tomatoes are peeled and diced before entering the can, making it easy to use. You can use them to make stews and soups, apart from sauces. The diced tomatoes are also reasonably priced, adding to Muir Glen’s pros list.

Check Price on Amazon


5. Tuttorosso 100% Natural Crushed Tomatoes

Tuttorosso Natural Crushed Tomatoes Product Image

Tuttorosso tops the chart whenever it comes to crushed tomatoes brands. Crushed tomatoes are an ideal kitchen ingredient for preparing sauces, stews, or soups. They almost taste similar to Whole and diced tomatoes, but since they are mashed tomatoes in a can, they save a lot of effort in preparing sauces.

Just open the can with a can opener, pour it into your cookware, and cook for your favorite soup or sauce recipe. Tuttorosso helps the consumer achieve that through their online presence. They can consist of 100% natural tomatoes mashed after peeling off their skin and then packed into an ergonomic can. Each can of Tuttorosso comes with basil which is a natural preservative. Apart from that, no other additives are used.

The most prominent feature that distinguishes best canned crushed tomatoes is the color. It has a cherry red color within which yellow seeds can be seen floating. The mix is thick and does not contain any fat. Tuttorosso is a well-known brand that provides you with the best canned Italian tomatoes in mashed form.

What we like about it:

Tomato sauces or stews, or soups fall under the categories of a quick snack. And already there are many jobs associated with the preparation of pasta or lasagna. Adding another job of mashing the tomatoes might kill the hunger. But this brand provides you with a ready-made ingredient rich in taste, texture, and simplicity.

The price is quite reasonable and saves time and effort. It also enhances the taste of continental dishes like bruschetta or pizza. Tuttorosso canned crushed tomatoes are devoid of added preservatives and fat, which helps the body stay fit and healthy.

Check Price on Amazon


6. 365 Everyday Value, Organic Diced Tomatoes, Fire Roasted

365 Everyday Value, Organic Diced Tomatoes, Fire Roasted, 14.5 oz

The leading brand in tomato production and processing is 365 Everyday Value. This company has had years of trusted operations. The diced tomatoes produced form the best addition to any delicacy you are preparing, and this is a sure way to keep your guests talking.

If you have been to California, then the San Joaquin Valley is the best place to visit and discover the best fertile soil for plant growth. The high-quality tomatoes used in making this canned organic diced tomato are grown in this valley. It takes a short time due to excellent soil conditions, and whatever you will be consuming is a result of natural nurturing. No additional components are used to increase the growth rate, and this gives these tomatoes a selling point and the trust you need in any grower.

You won’t miss this in pantries, fridges, and freezers, as it’s the reason why most kitchen lovers meet their cooking goals without struggling. The diced tomatoes are fat-free, sugar-free but contain some sodium and fiber to balance the nutrients you get from the tomatoes.

Buyers have trusted this brand as it’s Certified Organic, Certified Kosher, and Certified Vegan for you to buy with confidence.

What we liked about it:

Looking at the can, you will notice the careful details that guide you through the ingredients used when manufacturing these canned tomatoes. You will also find it a long-lasting type that guarantees you a long year stay, hence the 365 brandings. Perhaps you prefer having organic tomatoes in a large can; this is your deal as it is 14.5 oz. We also liked the sugar-free aspect and the natural ways of growing the tomatoes, ensuring that you are consuming a healthy product.

Check Price on Amazon


7. Del Monte Canned Quality Petite Cut Diced Tomatoes

Del Monte Canned Quality Petite Cut Diced Tomatoes, 14.5-Ounce

The fertile soils of the United States have had a history of producing the best quality crops. Tomatoes grown here are the number one grade and leading worldwide. Quality is the most sought-after thing in the USA, and processing this canned tomato goes through a competitive assessment to allow it on the market.

Apart from the quality assessment, the initial production of these tomatoes does not involve inorganic methods and will follow strictly organic and safe ways of planting to give you quality products for your best health. There are no additives or artificial flavors added during manufacturing, making it even the tastiest of all the dishes you plan to prepare. Talking of the dishes, you will bank on these Del Monte canned tomatoes as they offer a great addition to various dishes.

The 14.5-ounce canned tomatoes offer a sure way that the value meets your investment, and you will use it for some time. The dice are cut carefully and will look lovely on top of any meal, and this not only attracts visitors but also give the meal an appealing taste.

Some of the components used in producing these diced tomatoes include sodium chloride, potassium, fiber, and carbohydrates. All these are essential for your body and hence the best addition to your tasty tomatoes. They also act as a preservative for canned tomatoes.

What we liked about it:

The first thing is that the type is manufactured in the USA, where quality is always a top priority, and since it’s in the market, the quality is impeccable. Furthermore, growing tomatoes does not involve inorganic processes; hence, the end product is safe for consumption.

Check Price on Amazon

8. Mutti Finely Chopped Tomatoes

Mutti Finely Chopped Tomatoes, 14 oz. Can, 12-Pack

The Mutti Finely Chopped Tomatoes is a darling to people who love tasty meals. The Italian-made canned tomatoes bring the most flavorful foods for your family. It’s a 14-ounce capacity and comes in a pack of 12. If you buy it as a pack, be assured of saving a lot and getting discounts on top.

This is the number one brand of tomatoes in Italy, and the success goes back to the taste, freshness, and quality. The finely chopped tomatoes feature some Mediterranean salt to give it an excellent taste and add nutritional value. It’s attractive as the striking red color brings out the trueness of the tomato and will give your food the correct taste. In addition to this, the fantastic flavor leaves your tongue feeling the bite.

If your health is a priority, this is the best way to treat the body with a sugar-free, gluten-free, non-GMO with no added additives. It’s all-natural and gives your body what it needs to mature naturally.

No Italian meal is complete without the Mutti Chopped Tomatoes, and that’s why it’s all over the shelf’s fridges and kitchen cabinets.

What we liked about it:

It’s the number one brand in Italy and never misses shelves. You will find it everywhere. We also love that it is additive-free, non-GMO, non-PBA, and gluten-free. Finally, the tomato is ideal for various foods and hence the best for kitchen lovers.

Check Price on Amazon


9. Organico Bello – Organic Southern Italian Whole Peeled Tomatoes

Organico Bello - Organic Southern Italian Whole Peeled Tomatoes - 14.28oz (Pack of 12) - Non GMO, Whole 30 Approved, Gluten Free, BPA Free

Have you had the taste of the Southern Italian tomatoes? Organic Bello has the solution to all your delicacies. An addition of this tomato makes the real difference. It will make the food delicious and supply the nutrients required for the better functioning of your body.

These whole peeled tomatoes contain non-artificial preservatives. Additionally, the tomatoes are non-GMO. No added sugar and no added water make the quality outstanding. You will not be consuming the usual tomatoes on the market, but the high-quality product is manufactured with care.

If you like buying things in bulk, then the pack of 12cans each 14.3 oz will be the best pick for you, and the prices, when purchased as a pack, are way much lower. The package means that you won’t be a frequent visitor to your retailer as the plenty quantity will serve you for some time.

Certification for every product is critical, which means the quality has been accepted. For Organic Bello, the USDA certification ensures that the product is excellent for consumption. Once the cans are used, they are recyclable, the best way to keep the environment clean.

What we liked about it:

We pointed out so many factors in Organic Bello tomatoes that are irresistible. However, some were so striking. The pack of 12 cans makes the purchase cheaper. The gluten-free aspect and non-GMO components also make the type healthy for you and the entire family.

Finally, the tomatoes are stored in nice cans that are easy to open, and you only pull up the lid and use it. These cans also improve the beauty of your kitchen.

Check Price on Amazon


10. LoveSome Diced Tomatoes

LoveSome Diced Tomatoes, 14.5 Ounce

Diced tomatoes reduce the hustle of chopping the tomatoes to prepare your meal. The whole process has been done for you. LoveSome brings some love to your kitchen, and that’s why the brand has kept on attracting hundreds of users each passing day.

If you happen to be part of the LoveSome users, you will have many benefits. It’s not only healthy but also tasty, and your meals will have a taste of sweetness and savory flavor. The can is easy to open and use, and it adds up as a reusable type making it environmentally friendly.

The quality is flawless and has passed all the standards laid in the USA manufacturing industries. It’s a healthy type as it features no GMOs, no cholesterol, no fats, gluten-free, among other components. However, it comes with a certain percentage of minerals such as sodium, carbohydrates, and fiber, which add up as excellent minerals for your body.

What we liked about it:

First, the can is reusable, which means the environment will remain safe. It’s also a USA brand and the rigorous quality assessment done is a sure way that the product you will be consuming is standard. It also comes in a large quantity of 14.5oz, enough for your meals. Finally, you can use the LoveSome Diced Tomatoes to spice up plenty of your favorite dishes.

Check Price on Amazon


How do we choose the best-canned tomatoes?

We selected the top 10 canned Italian tomatoes after an extensive literature survey. We did exploratory research to find out the available products on the market. We browsed through popular online shopping sites to know the products well. After that, we made the list of best-canned tomatoes brands and checked with other websites for cross-reference. The brands which appeared on two or more sites were taken into consideration.

We considered the following aspects for the selection:

  • Aesthetics: The packaging and nutrient constituents were inspected. The tomatoes grow in vines, and there are several ways to ripen the tomatoes, which is why it is required to understand how the tomatoes were grown, picked, processed.
  • Technical Processes: It determines how the tomatoes are packed into the cans. The farming techniques are also considered. The organic tomatoes are rich in texture, but the items were selected based on the certified methods and if the brands truly bind with the framework proposed by the food industry.
  • Business reputation: The mission, vision, and the background of the families associated with the business were also considered. After all, a family with good knowledge about what they produce can develop a good product for the consumers.

After checking these aspects, we went through the customer reviews and feedback for different brands available on the internet. We came up with a comprehensive evaluation of the best-canned tomatoes brands mentioned above.

Which is the best-canned tomatoes brand?

Types of Canned Tomatoes

Tomatoes are not easy to store, and hence various brands use added preservatives to canned tomatoes to increase their durability. These added preservatives are mainly salt, citric acid, vinegar, or calcium chloride. Citric acid is naturally present in tomatoes which acts as an acid regulator but added citric acid imparts a sour taste to the tomatoes and helps store them over time. The canned tomatoes have a broad classification based on the type of tomatoes present inside the can. Following is the list of different kinds of canned tomatoes:

  • Whole Peeled: This is one of the most common forms of canned tomatoes. The tomatoes are packed as a whole tomato only with their skins peeled off primarily through steam peeling. They come in tasty puree or juice.
  • San Marzano: A specific variety of Italian tomatoes, plum, and firm. They are grown in Italy and have a rich texture and superior flavor, making them ideal for sauces.
  • Diced: These are long chopped pieces of tomatoes generally halved, ideal for tomato recipes.
  • Crushed: Tomatoes are crushed to tiny pieces that are ideal for soups.
  • Puree: Pureed tomatoes are thicker and more profound in flavors. Each brand makes pureed tomatoes in its way, giving them different flavors.
  • Stewed: They are softer than whole peeled and are generally cooked with seasonings.
  • Sauce: Puree tomatoes with added water and some seasonings give the sauce.
  • Paste: The paste is obtained by heating the pulp mashed in water. After evaporation, the residue is called paste.

Why do you need the Best Canned Tomatoes?

  • Canned tomatoes have low calories. Tomatoes also contain Vitamin C and fiber. Though the canning process may destroy vitamin C and fiber, the farm picked tomatoes to have a rich amount of vitamin C, protecting your body from different diseases.
  • Canned tomatoes are flushed with antioxidants that slow down the process of fermentation. Thus, they help in reducing different physical problems. Some of them are heart disease, prostate cancer, and poor eyesight as you get older.
  • They do not contain any fat or trans-fat, or cholesterol. Thus, consuming canned tomatoes of the best quality brands also reduces the risk of obesity.
  • Canned tomatoes are versatile and can be used in various ways. One can directly eat from the can,  cook them, serve with salads, soups or stews, and continental dishes.
  • Canned tomatoes give you various options to use in any way you want. You can use them as a whole in your low carbohydrate diet or use the puree on the pizza from your pizza oven to enhance the taste. You can use the diced tomatoes in bruschetta or crushed tomatoes into the soup from your pressure cooker. It saves a lot of time and effort.
  • Some of the diced tomato cans contain calcium chloride. The additive helps the tomatoes to retain their shape. The addition of calcium chloride helps them keep the form during and even after cooking. So, if you or your guests want the chunk of tomatoes intact in their dishes, canned tomatoes provide you with the option.