Here’s a list of the ten best butcher papers this 2021. To create this particular list, we recruited the opinions and aid of several of our friends, family members, colleagues, as well as professional chefs and pit-masters from barbecue restaurants. In reality, we were happy to have just about anyone experienced in southern-style cooking. Once we collected all the opinions, we assessed the pros and cons of each product on the recommended list.
Barbecue can be a complicated process, but the rewards are worth it. A lot of people asked us to create this list because they wanted to know if butcher paper is indeed a better, healthier option when compared to aluminum foil. They also wanted to know which brand of butcher paper is the most affordable and the most durable. Although it was a bit difficult to find some brands on this list, we still managed to push through. Out of around 15 entries, we had to narrow it down to 10 after conducting plenty of research and testing:
Best Butcher Paper Review Center
| Image | Butcher Paper | Rating |
|---|---|---|
 | #1 - Bryco Goods Pink Kraft Butcher Paper Roll | 99% |
 | #2 - Oren International Pink Butcher Paper Kraft Roll | 97% |
 | #3 - NY Paper Mill Brown Butcher Paper Roll | 96% |
 | #4 - DIY Crew Butcher Paper Roll | 94% |
 | #5 - Mighty Dreams Butcher Paper Roll | 92% |
 | #6 - Papertastic Paper Co. Pink Butcher Paper Roll | 90% |
 | #7 - StoneTipp Pink Butcher Paper Roll | 89% |
 | #8 - Creative Paper Co. Brown Kraft Paper Jumbo Roll | 86% |
 | #9 - Land Work Provisions Peach Butcher Paper Roll | 85% |
 | #10 - HeyMate Brown Kraft Butcher Paper Roll | 84% |
We thoughtfully selected each of these ten best butcher papers. We settled upon our list after extensive research, detailed testing procedures, and impartial assessments.
#1 – Bryco Goods Pink Kraft Butcher Paper Roll
Bryco Goods has a nice Pink Kraft Butcher Paper Roll. This measures over 1.5 feet in width and around 175 feet in length for the entire roll. It’s a butcher paper that complies with FDA standards. This handy butcher paper helps you smoke all sorts of meat, and the product is made in the USA. It is uncoated, unbleached, and has no wax coating.
This is a company that is known for making very durable butcher papers. The Bryco Goods Pink Kraft Butcher Paper Roll lets you smoke all of your meats for several hours, without having to worry over whether the paper is going to rip off or break. Wrap and store your leftovers and newly-cooked foods alike. The material of this paper makes it durable and prevents leakage and drips.
The lack of a wax coating makes the paper safe to use. You can be sure your food preserves its flavor, too, since this paper doesn’t have any chemical coating. Bryco Goods’ butcher paper is made from 100% all-natural virgin pulp, which helps keep the purity and flavor of your meats.
You can use this food-grade butcher paper as a way to serve, smoke, wrap, and store your food. It doesn’t even have to be just for food, either. That’s because it’s also great for arts and crafts, or for the bottom of your birdcage, which help you clean it up easily.
What We Like About It:
Our tester’s husband is an avid barbecue fan. He uses his grill and smoker almost every weekend. His favorite meats to cook are pork shoulders and brisket. The 2 of them tried it out to rest the meat on after it was done grilling. According to our tester, it worked much better than using foil, which is what her husband previously used.
Bryco Goods’ butcher paper is also a brand that has been trusted by so many barbecuing experts, so our tester figured that there was something unique about it. The paper works excellently. It wrapped up the meats easily, and it stayed on for a long time. The material that the paper is made of is of excellent quality and also comes at an amazing price.
#2 – Oren International Pink Butcher Paper Kraft Roll
Oren International’s own Pink Butcher Paper Kraft Roll has a measurement of 18 inches by 150 inches. It has also been approved by the FDA and is made in the USA. This paper is highly recommended for barbecuing your brisket, wrapping leftover or newly-grilled meats, and smoking a brisket. It is crafted from the finest all-natural ingredients, is uncoated, unwaxed, and unbleached.
This is a paper that smokes aluminum foil. It can absorb the heat coming from the meat itself and resists moisture, which allows your meat to “breathe” for a short while after it’s been rested from the grill. This helps it create the perfect bark. Plenty of celebrity barbecue pit-masters have endorsed this butcher paper, including Aaron Franklin. The roll also comes with a DCT Packaging Tube and an accompanying e-book called The Bare Bones of BBQ.
This particular paper does not contain any foreign chemicals, wax, bleach, or other ingredients that could potentially affect the look and taste of your meat. It has gone through plenty of testing, which helps give it the best kind of endurance, prevents any spills or leaks from happening. It is also excellent for wrapping, cooking, storing meats, lining barbecue trays, serve fries, ribs, and hamburgers.
What We Like About It:
This paper was just awesome, according to our tester. He works at a barbecue joint and has been grilling for over two decades. It takes him 18 hours to make a brisket, and after that, it goes right onto the barbecue. One of the most challenging parts of the whole process is not to lose the bark. Previously, he used to wrap the brisket around in foil to cook the meat overnight.
Ever since he found Oren International’s butcher paper, the process is so much faster than before. He simply leaves the brisket unwrapped for only a few hours instead of overnight. He now swears by this brand every time he barbecues. One of the things he cooked is pork shoulder, and it came out looking juicy and tasty.
#3 – NY Paper Mill Brown Butcher Paper Roll
As its brand name suggests, the NY Paper Mill Brown Butcher Paper Roll is completely made in the USA. It strictly follows the standard FDA procedures regarding creating the best butcher paper, making it a healthy and safe choice for you and your family.
This type of butcher paper has also been selected by so many barbecue experts that love creating a Texas-style barbecue. The paper is durable enough to keep the meat protected from the smoker. At the same time, the high breathability allows the steam from the smoker to escape the wrapping without doing any damage. This will result in a juicy and flavorful barbecue without doing damage to the paper itself. There is also less chance of developing a soggy exterior bark.
The paper is crafted from all-natural materials, in which there is no wax or polymer coating, which can be hazardous when ingested. NY Paper Mill only uses virgin pulp to create their products. Plus, their butcher paper is made from a type of formulated treatment on the inside of the paper’s structure, providing it with a bit of an additional boost to the paper’s strength. Thus, instead of getting all soggy and potentially ripping apart, the paper remains durable when it is soaked in oil and water.
What We Like About It:
The person we lent this paper to used it for something outside of barbecue – as material for her heat-press projects. The paper stayed intact despite the heat and didn’t burn to a crisp. It also came in a rather big size, which was bigger than your average butcher paper. The ink didn’t bleed through the paper either, and the paper did an amazing job, as one would expect from it. She also used the same paper as a wrapping for giving away gifts, which worked very well.
#4 – DIY Crew Butcher Paper Roll
You can use this paper to create the most magnificent briskets and barbecues. It is approved by the FDA and is excellent for meat-smoking and grilling on the barbecue. It is a natural, unbleached paper with a measurement of 24 inches x 200 feet.
The paper is suitable if you’re fond of making the traditional Texas-style brisket commonly seen in barbecue and Southern-style restaurants. It’s great for smoking and wrapping meat because it allows the brisket to breathe and reach the best temperature for serving. With this paper, you can get the best and tastiest bark for the meat, as well as that signature sweet and smoky flavor.
This paper is top-notch and one of the best out there. It gives superior holdout and won’t become soggy from oil, humidity, or blood from the meat. It also won’t break apart easily, either, especially when it’s covered in the meat juice and oil. Also, it comes in the traditional pink color for butcher papers. DIY Crew’s paper is all-natural and does not come with any wax coating.
What We Like About It:
Our tester thinks that pink butcher paper is so much better than the regular brown color or aluminum foil, especially when it comes to cooking barbecue. He tends to wrap his brisket using the paper and places it back on the smoker until it’s tender. Then, he takes it out again to rest. After using DIY Crew’s paper, it ended up looking and tasting fresh and juicy, not to mention the bark was excellent. Once, he tried cooking barbecue without the help of butcher paper by sticking to regular aluminum foil. It overcooked and didn’t come out as juicy as he hoped.
This is an excellent product that comes at a fantastic price. Our tester wants to keep using it for his other barbecues, especially since he has plans to join a cook-off later this year. He says that you can never really go wrong with this purchase, and it comes in handy whenever he needs to get cooking or to grill some meat for his friends and family.
#5 – Mighty Dreams Butcher Paper Roll
This butcher paper is part of a set. There’s the paper roll itself, a durable carrying tube that keeps the roll tidy and serves as its container, as well as an e-book about how to become a grill master. You can also use this paper as a type of food warmer. It has a measurement of 24 inches by 150 feet, and it comes in two colors: pink and peach. It does not have a wax coating or any other harmful chemicals added to it.
The paper is composed of 100% FDA Food Grade Paper, which makes it suitable for direct food contact. It’s made from pure virgin wood pulp and works better than aluminum foil. This is because the main ingredient here is a type of pulp that has been engineered to be resistant to both moisture and heat, which lets your barbecue breathe and relax – enhancing the moisture, texture, and flavor of the meat.
It’s also got the most amazing wet strength. Wet strength is very important for butcher papers because they can help you avoid any messes, spills, or accidents whenever you cook, rest, or cut your brisket into slices. The best part is that there’s no wax coating in the paper to aid its durability.
What We Like About It:
This paper caused our tester to start cooking brisket for the very first time. He was glad he followed the instructions that came with this product’s accompanying e-book, and he was able to produce meat that was fork-tender and cut easily. The paper was also high-quality, which is simply amazing. It was able to absorb plenty of the fat, while the brisket itself rested on the table for two hours. The paper allowed the air to escape, which was something that couldn’t be done with aluminum foil.
#6 – Papertastic Paper Co. Pink Butcher Paper Roll
This company has been making butcher papers for the longest time. This roll weighs around 40 pounds and has met the approval of the FDA, which means it’s completely safe to use around food. You can get the best butcher paper from Papertastic Paper Co. without having to spend too much. The product is also all-natural, which means they don’t use coatings, bleach, or wax.
There aren’t any toxic or dangerous polymers or any other chemical included in the making of this paper, so it is completely safe to eat or use while cooking. You can utilize this highly-durable paper for barbecue parties or cookouts with the family. This paper is used once the last part of the grilling process is done. You can switch from aluminum foil to this paper and use it for your ribs or brisket once they are cooked. The material lets your barbecue breathe while it’s resting and retains its flavor and moisture. It also prevents it from getting over-smoked.
Papertastic Paper Co.’s products all go through a specially formulated process to further increase its strength and durability. This product has high wet strength, which stops the paper from ripping or falling apart, especially if it’s soaked with too much oil or meat juice.
What We Like About It:
This is an amazing product. Our tester claims that it works similarly, if not better, to the butcher paper he previously used, but isn’t as expensive. The quality is just excellent, and he managed to get it for half the price. It’s an essential tool if you want to smoke meats, like ribs or pork shoulder, in his case. His pork shoulder still had the bark on it, which wouldn’t have happened if he had used aluminum foil instead.
#7 – StoneTipp Pink Butcher Paper Roll
StoneTipp is a company that is reputable for creating the best butcher paper around. They seem to have developed a loyal following among butchers and barbecue pit-masters everywhere. In regards to smoking nothing but the best brisket, each detail counts. StoneTipp’s butcher paper is there to regulate your meat’s moisture, as well as the amount of heat and smoke that surrounds it. This ensures the best smoking condition for your barbecue, every time.
The paper is all-natural. It has never been waxed or bleached, and it is not coated with any potentially toxic chemical that can seep into your meat while you cook. Your food will come out safe and healthy, not to mention consumable. However, that doesn’t necessarily mean that the paper itself is weak. StoneTipp’s butcher paper has been designed to retain its structure and strength, especially while it’s covered in oil or drenched with water. The paper comes inside a heavy-duty poly bag that you can use to keep it dry and safe.
You can also use this paper for storing your food, smoking meat, arts, and crafts, as a gift wrap, or as placemats. Besides, it is excellent if you want to serve greasy fries, burgers, or pizza for dinner. Not only does it make your food look elegant, but it cleans up easily too.
What We Like About It:
Our tester immediately tried out this butcher paper by wrapping up a smoked pork loin that he bought from the supermarket. The paper kept the meat moist, but not to the point of being soggy. The paper still kept its amazing quality, even after he took it out from the smoker. Meanwhile, his kids also used this paper to create beautiful artwork using colored pencils the paper gives the art an antique look and feel.
#8 – Creative Paper Co. Brown Kraft Paper Jumbo Roll
Creative Paper Co.’s butcher paper has a measurement of 17.75 inches x 1200 inches. Not only is it handy for barbecuing, but it’s also great for arts, crafts, packing, shipping, and using as a gift wrap. It is completely made in the USA and is purely industrial grade. There is no wax coating on the paper, and it is completely eco-friendly.
The same company also practices fair-trade techniques and wants to be sure all of their clients are happy with their products. If they aren’t, for some reason, then the customer can initiate a refund with the company, and the company will refund their money without any further question or provide them a better roll of butcher paper for free.
What We Like About It:
Our tester thought this paper was slightly thinner than the butcher’s paper that she normally used, but in her case, she wanted to utilize it for arts and crafts. She hoped that it carried the same thickness as the average cheap copy paper, but it wasn’t the same. However, she still decided to use it for wrapping paper and her artwork.
#9 – Land Work Provisions Peach Butcher Paper Roll
Land Work’s butcher paper can be used for a whole assortment of reasons, but its main purpose is for smoking meat, especially ribs or brisket or anything you can cook on the barbecue. Outside of cooking, it’s great for wrapping paper, packing paper, kitchen table placemats, delivering food, and even for storage.
The paper is also highly affordable, and measures over 200 feet! It’s the best bang for your buck. It’s also the restaurant industry standard, and the paper’s wet strength is great. It’s pretty tough, as well, and can withstand even the hottest barbecue pits and smokers.
Land Work Provisions’ paper is completely unbleached, unwaxed, and does not contain harmful chemicals. It is made from the best and most natural ingredients. You won’t find any polymer coating in the paper, either. It’s also helpful for the environment, too, because this paper, in particular, is constructed from recycled pulps, making them more sustainable.
What We Liked About It:
This paper carries a decent weight and also features a decent size. It’s the best paper for wrapping up a delicious barbecue after it comes off the grill or smoker, including ribs, sausages, pork shoulder, and brisket. That was the main reason why our tester decided to purchase it. It was an excellent alternative to wrapping the meat up with foil, which would have resulted in soggy brisket. This product, meanwhile, helped the meat retain its juiciness without the bark of the brisket becoming mushy.
#10 – HeyMate Brown Kraft Butcher Paper Roll
This paper has a measurement of 24 inches by 2,100 inches long. It has met the approval of the FDA, meaning it can make direct contact with your food. It is also non-stick with food for quick and easy removals. This makes the product safe to use, not to mention a healthier choice to serve your barbecue meals.
The product is completely unbleached and is made from the best and most natural ingredients around, including virgin pulp. You won’t find any wax or chemical coating on it, either. The paper itself is designed to be strong and resistant to moisture and heat. It can spread moisture and heat around evenly, instead. The meat can also suck in the grease and oil, locking in the flavor.
What We Like About It:
The paper comes at a medium weight and is very versatile. It’s got plenty of uses too. In the case of our tester, it works well for certain artistic projects. She was looking for a good roll of utility paper and loved the fact that the product came with an accompanying stand-in. The stand-in is comprised of tees, elbows, and a plumbing pipe. Although it was easy to assemble, the paper wasn’t very expensive, and it took only a small amount of effort to set up. The legs of the stand-in had their own set of rubber feet, so the paper won’t slide around.
Before you’ve decided to choose the butcher paper that is the best for you, consider the following first: make sure the product is FDA-approved, so it can safely come into contact with your food. The material must also be durable and strong enough to resist oil and water. Owning the best butcher paper not only means getting to cook the most flavorful barbecues, but it also means those who enjoy your barbecues stay safe and healthy.
Choosing the most suitable butcher paper for your needs may still be challenging, even when we have carefully laid out a list of the ten best butcher papers this year. To help you further narrow down your decision, we have identified the most relevant factors to consider when choosing, as they can greatly affect your experience. We are here to help you out by presenting you with a checklist of important factors to keep in mind as you review our top 10 list of the best butcher papers this year. Check out the factors below:
Factors to Consider When Buying Best Butcher Paper
FDA-Approved
Having your butcher paper of choice approved by the FDA means that it is safe to be in contact with the food you plan to consume. In turn, this means that the process by which your butcher paper was manufactured is deemed safe and chemical-free. If you intend to use your butcher paper on the grill or smoker for those tasty briskets or ribs, keep in mind that you need to look for products that have this special approval. Otherwise, you risk getting yourself, your family and your friends sick;
Durable
When it comes to using butcher paper for grilling or smoking meats, you certainly don’t want to experience any rips or tears while you’re moving your meats around. You can avoid a catastrophic fall from the grill to the ground by selecting a durable butcher paper with a good weight to it. Also, if you plan to use your butcher paper for non-food purposes, you will still want a strong product. Arts and crafts require a good weight to hold marker ink or paint, and if you intend to use the butcher paper to pack delicate items, you certainly don’t want it to crumple up too easily;
Resistance to Moisture
Utilizing your choice of butcher paper for cooking or grilling means it will be subjected to a great deal of moisture, such as juice from the meat and cooking oils. The last thing you want, in this case, is a butcher paper that has been significantly weakened by moisture. If your butcher paper becomes too weak, it could tear, which could result in your meat burning in the smoker, where it will become tough and crispy. Therefore, when selecting the right butcher paper for your needs, be sure to consider how resistant it is to get wet, both with water and with oil; and
Cost
As much as we all hate to admit it, sometimes our choice of products all boils down to the cost. For some of us, butcher paper can be seen as an unnecessary luxury item, where we can afford to drop a big stack of cash on a single roll – no matter how durable and moisture-resistant it is! Of course, we now recognize how critical butcher paper is to our home, whether it’s for cooking purposes or arts and crafts purposes. Regardless, the impact it will have on our wallet is still a concern, so it’s critical to pay attention to the price tag when shopping around for the best butcher paper for you!
Do You Need Butcher Paper?
From steaks, ribs, sandwiches, and everything else that goes along with them, to become a responsible restaurant owner, you need to properly package your food to lock in its freshness and ensure that it’s safe for your clients to eat and enjoy.
Thus, finding out which type of butcher paper, or food-wrapping paper in general, to use for this purpose is critical to providing in the highest quality service to your clients.
You might not even realize this, but butcher paper is often included in lists of essential materials one must-have in the home. It may look ordinary and dull, but butcher paper is affordable, practical, versatile, and durable. It can be used for all sorts of purposes, including food, arts, and crafts, or even as gift wrap.
Butcher paper is a sturdy and coarse paper that you can use to cover meat and seafood recipes. People that commonly utilize this paper include crafters, butchers, and fishmongers. The raw materials that are used in butcher paper include wood pulp, and it is made using a technique known as the Kraft process. The process manages to preserve the cellulose found in wood as a way to build a stronger product. This is the reason why butcher paper pulp has a grainy, coarse texture – a result of all those fibers being present.
Therefore, the short answer to whether you need butcher paper is yes — you need butcher paper, at the very least, for properly packaging foods in your home or restaurant. Other creative uses for butcher paper can range from arts and crafts to packing paper or gift wrap. Of course, we do suggest that you select the best butcher paper to suit your specific needs, so you can be confident the butcher paper that you choose will serve your purposes precisely as you hoped, whether that is as food packing material or for creative project material!
For this reason, we carefully created this list of the top 10 butcher papers this year. Our goal was a meticulously planned list that will help you make the most informed decision when it comes to choosing the best butcher paper for you. We also recommend that you review the checklist at the end of our selection before checking out our top 10 list. If you keep these factors in mind while browsing through our top 10 roundup, you are sure to identify the ideal product for your needs more quickly and effectively.
However, before you jump into exploring our detailed reviews, take a moment to learn about the pros and cons of using butcher paper. You might be surprised at them, and they can also help you identify the best brand of butcher paper for your home as you look more closely at our top 10 butcher papers this 2021. Here we go:
Butcher Papers Pros
Strength and Durability
The brands of butcher paper listed in our collection are all made of top-of-the-line materials. This relatively high-density paper is sturdy and robust, even under challenging conditions, such as moisture, ink, and heavyweight. Butcher papers are strong enough to handle your beautiful China during a move delicately, but also delicate enough to display your child’s best artwork to date;
Cleanliness and Protection
When it comes to protecting your meats and seafood, butcher paper is second to none. It prevents airborne contaminants from ruining your foods and potentially causing illness in the patrons of your restaurant. Also, butcher papers preserve flavor and help keep less-appealing smells from tainting your food;
Low Cost
We did not design this list to rip off our readers. Most of the butcher papers we included on our list are extraordinarily cost-effective! This age-old type of paper has a manufacturing process that has been refined over many years, providing us with this superb product at a meager cost; and
Versatility
Butcher papers are not only for butchers! Although it originally was designed for butchers to use in protecting their meats and seafood, the modern uses of butcher papers have increased many times over. Not only can it protect and preserve raw foods, but it can also act as a never-ending roll of coloring paper, a low-cost wrapping paper, and any other creative use you can imagine for it.
Now that you know the pros of butcher papers, it is only fair to evaluate the cons, as well. For you to objectively decide which brand is the best for your needs, you need the entire picture. Read on for the cons of butcher papers:
Butcher Papers Cons
Plainness
If you’re looking for discount wrapping paper for presents, you will not find butcher papers decorated with “Happy Birthday” or “Merry Christmas.” These papers are designed to be plain in color, but the colors can vary to add some variety to your gift wrapping; and
Large Quantity Options
More often than not, butcher papers come in large rolls containing up to hundreds of square feet of material. If you are looking to wrap a few cuts of meat around the holidays, a normal roll of butcher papers will be far too much. The same goes for if you are looking for a simple sheet of paper for your son or daughter to doodle on while you make dinner at night. These large rolls can be relatively expensive and challenging to store, as well.
Now you know some of the pros and cons of butcher papers, which you should keep in mind while you check out the products listed in our top 10 collections. Naturally, we chose the most important factors when considering the best butcher papers for your needs. These factors are based upon exhaustive research, detailed evaluations, and impartial assessments, and they are presented in a manner that is easily digested. As such, you’ll find it fast and easy to find the best butcher papers for your home.
Now that you have read over the most relevant factors to consider when you’re reviewing the products in our roundup of the top 10 best butcher papers this 2021, you are prepared to make the best decision to suit your needs. You have the power of knowledge when it comes to making this critical decision and the butcher paper that you ultimately select to be an exact fit for your purpose. We wish you happy hunting as you work toward identifying the best product for you from our selection of the top 10 best butcher papers this year!