The one thing that perplexes all enthusiastic bakers is the struggle they meet while looking for the perfect food coloring that will go with your cooking or bakery.
It’s a necessity that it incorporates well into what you’re making, while at the same time adding a lively, appealing visual.
Moreover, it’s taste shouldn’t be sensible alongside the original flavor of the dish or dessert, and it absolutely must not alter it in any way.
The difficulty stems from the fact that the majority of the food dyes on the market either fail to give a satisfying color or have a disappointingly apparent taste that interferes with the gustatory experience. That’s why we are to help you pick the most satisfying coloring agent that will make you happy, and we have tried every one on the market just to hand you the best of the best!
Food Coloring Review Center 2021
| Image | Food Coloring | Rating |
|---|---|---|
 | #1 - AmeriColor Student Gel Food Coloring | 99% |
 | #2 - Wilton Icing Colors | 94% |
 | #3 - Good Cooking Gel Colors | 88% |
 | #4 - LorAnn Food Coloring Powder | 82% |
 | #5 - Watkins Assorted Food Coloring | 75% |
Want to learn more?
Now that you’ve seen our top 5 recommendations, we’ll give you more detail on each of them, including why we liked them. When you’re ready, click the yellow button to get the best price on Amazon.
#1 – AmeriColor Student Gel Food Coloring
A color kit that has twelve colors to choose from, offering an outstanding variety, the AmeriColor Student is undoubtedly one of the best to exist.
It contains the common colors such as red, blue and yellow that are staples when it comes to dying food, alongside harder to find hues like black and brown. All in all, you won’t have to look further for any color you might need, as it covers the whole spectrum of usable ones, thanks to the diversity it offers.
Additionally, these pigments go along well with many kinds of food elements, and it will always come out as satisfactory whether you use it for your strong dye needs like frostings and bakery or more intricate usage when dealing with frailer substances like a whipped topping.
Moreover, it never breaks down, and it always forms a homogenous mix with whatever you use it in.
Finally, it is quite a strong coloring, so it is to be used sparingly, and it is sold in easy to squeeze bottles, which is efficient and enables better measuring.
What we like about it
Different colors, strong flavor, and wide food compatibility. What else could a baker ask for? Prepare your Baker’s Rack, grab your Baking Tools, and unleash your creativity.
#2 – Wilton Icing Colors
Wilton is a widely respected brand in the business of baking decorations, and it is renowned for its’high-quality products, and their food coloring is certainly no exception.
It is also kosher, which is a plus. Its’ palette of colors includes 8 shades, violet, red, yellow, blue, pink, brown, green, and orange.
Akin to the previous product, using a tiny bit of it can go a long way as it gives the desired tone without necessitating a great amount, which results in preserving the texture as well as the taste of the colored food.
If you’re one to customize your colors, then you’ve hit the jackpot because these dyes mix well together and produce new colors that adhere to your preferences, so basically, the color options are limited only by your imagination!
What we like about it
What we really dig about this food colorant is the limitless opportunities it offers. Just get your Bakeware Set, and the sky becomes the limit when it comes to the possibilities.
#3 – Good Cooking Gel Colors
This color dye collection provides a broad spectrum of colors that make up for a significant number of possible choices. These include pink, yellow, red, royal blue, black, sky blue, brown, fuschia, orange, and two different green tones.
This coloring is thick and has the texture of a gel, that’s why it is shinier and more opaque when it compares to other dyes, which means that you can use even less to get more out of it.
Moreover, when used, it mixes in smoothly into whatever you’re making regardless of the nature of it. For example, even when used with frozen desserts, such as Ice Cream, it will definitely form a homogeneous combination.
Its usage is adequate alongside most ingredients and won’t clash with any of them, particularly soft toppings and icings and among those whipped ones. Yes, you can get your new Whipped Cream Dispenser.
Finally, It comes in easily manageable bottles that provide exceptional control when it comes to the quantity you’re adding, so you don’t make the dire mistake of overdoing which is irreversible.
What we like about it
Besides the broad color choices and the safe usage, we’re really fond of the easily manageable bottles. It’s also compatible with most frozen desserts, so you can safely include this colorant when you’re using your Ice Cream Maker and Ice Cream Scoops.
#4 – LorAnn Food Coloring Powder
LorAnn Food Coloring, unlike the other dyes that come in water-based forms, comes in powder form, which is the ideal case if you do not wish to use liquid coloring in your dish, for one reason or another.
It is also possible to use oil-based or liquid-based recipes as well as any dry mix you might be using. Its color palette includes seven different colors, namely blue, green, black, violet, yellow, orange, and red.
These hues will be effective when you’re in need of delicacy, especially when dealing with some types of dessert.
Additionally, its’ powder form gives you immense control over the amount of color you need, whether it is a light or a dark tone that you desire, you can achieve it with ease, while also giving darker color when compared to liquid ones, meaning using up less quantity for the same effect, thus making it last a longer while.
And most importantly, it won’t give off a certain taste when added: your food will taste the same without any alterations whatsoever, so you have no reason to refrain from using this awesome dye!
What we like about it
What we like most about this colorant is the versatility it offers as the powder form makes including it in any recipe quite the easy task. If you’re planning to get your Cookie Cookbook along with your Cookie Press, Cookie Scoop, and Cookie Sheet to bake some delicious dessert, this is the colorant that you need.
#5 – Watkins Assorted Food Coloring:
Watkins food coloring offer four food dyes that are completely natural, having in mind people who are concerned over stains, in general, containing artificial chemicals and being synthetic, something that is extremely looked down upon, while also giving an undesirable flavor and generally being unrecommended for health concerns.
This is why this brand has the edge over the other ones that offer similar products. Ingredients include natural juices extracted out of vegetables, alongside spices, and it has no artificial colors added to it.
As a bonus trait, it is also gluten-free, which makes it the perfect add-on when you’re using your Gluten Free Appliances. This product is the perfect one for anyone who is wary of the health risks associated with their food, while also having versatile needs that can be entirely fulfilled by this dye, as it can be used for a multitude of purposes regardless of the food it mixes in with.
The only thing that might be a setback is the relative of color variation, although it has the essential four shades that any cook tends to use a lot more often than the other ones, including green, yellow, blue and red. It comes in 35-milliliter bottles, which are enough to last you a long time.
What we like about it
Whether you’re building a Gingerbread House, preparing a beautiful Cake Stand, or experimenting with your Donut Maker, getting a proper food colorant is essential to get the best result. And believe me when I say, Watkins’ Assorted Food Coloring offers the versatility your food deserves.
While you’re here, check out some of our other baking accessories and other accessories!
Sources: