5 Best Jelly Roll Pans Reviews and Comparison

A jelly roll, also known as a Swiss log or roll cake, is a sponge cake rolled lengthwise into a cylindrical shape. The inside is filled with cream, icing, or jam to give this sweet treat texture and make each bite more interesting.

Since the jelly roll isn’t shaped like your average cake, it requires a container that’s wider and shallower than your standard cake pan. 

Jelly roll pans are typically available in either 15 ½ by 10 ½ inches or 18 by 12 a.k.a. a half-sheet pan. The sides are about an inch high, which makes it perfect for baking the sponge cake base, spreading the filling on it once cooled, and rolling it to make the perfect cake rolls.

There’s really not a lot that goes into buying jelly roll pans. You’re going to get the same results out of it whether you choose a cheap or expensive one. All the same, we wanted to be able to give you options for this type of bakeware. Check out our top selections in the list below.

Best Jelly Roll Pans Comparison & Rating

Want to Learn More?

Shopping online is becoming more of a necessity these days. So, if all you need are some new jelly roll pans, you don’t have to leave the house and drive to the tour. As you’ll read in the product information below, each of these is available for purchase on Amazon. Be sure to click the yellow buttons to know about the latest deals!

Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Pan

Nordic Ware, Jelly Roll Pan, Aluminum
Specifications

Dimensions

15.13 x 10.63 x 1 inches

Weight

1.34 pounds

Material

Aluminum

Item Model Number

44870

Rating: 97% Overall
98%
performance
98%
durability
97%
easy to clean
96%
heat distribution
Pros
  • The embossed grid pattern on Nordic Ware’s Jelly Roll Pan enhances the look and performance of our hugely popular baking pans.
  • The Exclusive Prism grid adds durability and provides easy release while also improving airflow for uniform crisping.
  • Natural aluminum affords the best possible heat dispersion to create perfectly browned baked goods every time.
  • Pure aluminum will never rust so you can expect to get years of use from this pan.
  • The pan is also reinforced with an encapsulated rim to prevent warping.
Cons
  • Could be scratched by other metal utensils
  • A bit big for some ovens
Verdict

If you are a serious baker, this jelly roll pan is a purchase worth making. The corrugated bottom keeps the baked goods and anything else up off the pan, and lets the oven cook the entire batch very evenly. The patterned bottom also helps prevent food from sticking to it. You can be sure that those cookies will be crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside. The hot oven air can circulate above and below whatever you are baking, giving you more even results.


USA Pan Jelly Roll Baking Pan and Bakeable Nonstick Cooling Rack

USA Pan Jelly Roll Baking Pan and Bakeable Nonstick Cooling Rack, Metal
Specifications

Dimensions

14.25 x 9.37 x 0.5 inches

Weight

2.6 pounds

Material

Aluminized Steel

Item Model Number

1605CR

Rating: 96% Overall
99%
performance
97%
durability
95%
easy to clean
94%
heat distribution
Pros
  • The USA Pan Nonstick Jelly Roll Set includes a 14. 25 x 9. 375 x 1-inch jelly roll pan and a 13. 75 x 8. 625 x 0. 56-inch jelly roll baking & cooling rack
  • This superb kitchen and baking combo is the perfect set for making Swiss rolls, cookies, and scones that bake evenly, cool uniformly and come out tasting great.
  • The cooling rack fits seamlessly inside the pan and provides home bakers with an easy way to add the perfect glaze or finish to your homemade baked goods. This raised position promotes uniform cooling among your baked items.
  • The nonstick coating on both the pan and the cooling rack means that your baked goods will release quickly and easily, leaving your cookie bottoms crispy and intact.
  • Both the jelly roll pan and the cooling rack are oven safe up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.
Cons
  • Cannot be washed in the dishwasher
  • Would warp if temperature exceeds 450 degrees Fahrenheit
  • A very large pan
Verdict

The USA Pan Nonstick Jelly Roll Set makes a great addition to your kitchen. It’s versatile enough to not just bake sheet cake for jelly rolls and cookies. Placing the rack on top of the pan also makes juicy chicken breasts and crispy bacon. Plus, you can leave the food or baked goods as is to cool on perfectly cool on the rack before serving or storing. And because it has a nonstick surface, handwashing both the rack and the pan requires minimal scrubbing as grease and gunk come off easily.


Gotham Steel 1389 Nonstick Copper Cookie Sheet and Jelly Roll Baking Pan

Gotham Steel 1389 Nonstick Copper Cookie Sheet and Jelly Roll Baking Pan 12" x 17" – 1 PACK, Brown
Specifications

Dimensions

17.59 x 11.81 x 1 inches

Weight

 2.5 pounds

Material

Aluminum With Titanium

Item Model Number

1389

Rating: 95% Overall
98%
performance
96%
durability
94%
easy to clean
92%
heat distribution
Pros
  • Gotham Steel’s Nonstick Cookie Sheet and Jelly Roll Pan is great for your baking needs.
  • Made from titanium to ensure that you have a durable product that will last through years of use
  • The pan can withstand high oven temperatures of up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.
  • The ceramic finish provides a true nonstick surface. No oil or butter ever needed.
  • In addition to making delicious cookies, brownies, and cakes, you can bake chicken and roast veggies on it, too.
  • Clean up is made easy! Just simply wipe with a cloth or throw it in the dishwasher.
Cons
  • This pan scratches easily.
  • Tends to warp when in the oven longer than 15 minutes at very high temperatures
  • Due to structure, baked food leftovers could accumulate on some spots that would be hard to scrub off.
Verdict

Like our top pick for jelly roll pans, this product from Gotham Steel doesn’t just bake cakes. It can also bake pizza and roast a piece of steak. It provides even heat distribution so food’s always perfectly cooked. Sponge cakes are fluffy on the inside while the meat is juicy when you cut into it. And true to its advertising, dishing out food and cleaning the pan afterward is truly easy peasy.


Doughmakers Jelly Roll Commercial Grade Aluminum Bake Pan

Doughmakers Jelly Roll Commercial Grade Aluminum Bake Pan 10 x 15
Specifications

Dimensions

15 x 10 x 0.75 inches

Weight

1 pound

Material

Aluminum

Item Model Number

10311

Rating: 94% Overall
97%
performance
95%
durability
93%
easy to clean
91%
heat distribution
Pros
  • This Doughmakers Jelly Roll Pan is great for jelly rolls, cookies, roasting vegetables, and more.
  • Made of premium heavy gauge, recyclable aluminum with strengthened handle areas for increased durability and ease of use
  • The pan features our original pebble pattern, which allows for airflow under baked goods for more even browning and quick release.
  • This non-coated bakeware's unique, natural nonstick properties mean consistent, reliable, and healthy results every time.
Cons
  • Thinner than most jelly roll pans
  • The sheet comes with a glued piece of paper over it which is fairly hard to remove.
Verdict

This Doughmakers pan makes a great value purchase. The aluminum alloy conducts heat well and is exceptionally durable. The patented pebble patterned surface on the inside of the pan creates an intrinsically nonstick surface. We have found that it at least equals but often exceeds that of PTFE or PFOA coated pans. The pebble pattern is part of the metal itself, so there is no coating to wear off or leach into food. Better still, this is a very green alternative since making and applying PTFE and PFOA emits greenhouse gasses and produces toxic byproducts.


Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan

Chicago Metallic Commercial II Traditional Uncoated 16-3/4 by 12-Inch Jelly-Roll Pan, Set of 2 -
Specifications

Dimensions

16.75 x 12 x 1.25 inches

Weight

4.66 pounds

Material

Aluminized Steel

Item Model Number

49823

Rating: 91% Overall
95%
performance
92%
durability
88%
easy to clean
89%
heat distribution
Pros
  • The Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan is truly versatile — great for jelly rolls, one-sheet dinners, and even reheating leftovers.
  • Made from heavy-weight aluminized steel for superior heat conduction and even baking
  • It also features wire rod reinforced rims to prevent warping.
  • Features a traditional, uncoated baking surface
  • The jelly roll set measures 16.75-inch by 12-inch by 1-inch.
  • Dishwasher safe, however, hand-washing is recommended to extend product life.
Cons
  • The bottom of the pan scratches easily.
  • Due to structure, baked food leftovers could accumulate on some spots that would be hard to scrub off.
  • Could retain drip stains on the pan after being washed
Verdict

The Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan Set is durable and easy to clean. The nonstick surface is ideal for a variety of sweet treats like pressed cookies, jelly rolls, and bars. While it says dishwasher-friendly, we recommend just handwashing these pans to make them last longer. In addition, they are easier to store when compared to other trays. 3 or 4 trays stack together in not much more space than a single tray. If you’re one to bake multiple times a week, consider getting this set to add to your bakeware collection.

Jelly Roll Pan Buyer's Guide

material

Make sure to get a pan that lets you cook and bake at high temperatures. Read the label to know what the highest temperature you can expose your bakeware to.

texture

A jelly roll pan with a textured and wavy surface allows distributes airflow when you’re baking the cake batter so the end result is a cake that’s more evenly baked.

price

Set a budget based on the type of jelly roll pan you intend to purchase. While high-end ones are expected to be durable, you don’t really have to spend a lot of money to buy pans that will provide years of use.

cleaning

Choose pans that you can handwash and are also dishwasher-safe.

accessories

Get more use out of jelly roll pans by purchasing accessories like a cooling rack. Roast the meat, bacon, or vegetables without worrying about oil dripping since the pan collects all of it. You also want to look for safety features like reinforced or easy-to-grip sides so even kids can use them for baking with supervision.

FAQs

What are the common sizes of jelly roll pans?

The average jelly roll pan can fall in either one of these two sizes.

  • 5 by 15.5 inches (27 x 39 cm)

  • 5 by 17.5 inches (32 x 44.5 cm)

In both cases, the standard height of the edges is 1 inch (2.54 cm).

What’s the difference between a jelly roll pan or a cookie sheet pan?

A cookie sheet pan doesn’t have raised edges except on one side. This allows the hot air flow from each side so the cookies are baked evenly. It’s also much more comfortable to take cookies out of this kind of baking sheet with a spatula.

What are jelly roll pans made of?

Jelly roll pans are typically made from metal — stainless steel, aluminum, or aluminized steel. However, you can also find ones made from silicone or have a non-stick ceramic coating on them for easy cake transfer.

How do I remove greasy buildup on jelly roll pans?

Grab a non-abrasive scrubbing pad, liquid dish detergent (preferably Dawn), and baking soda. Wet the pan, add a few pumps of the dish detergent on the scrubbing pad and then sprinkle it with baking soda. Clean and rinse. This will bring new life to stainless steel, aluminum, and copper sheet pans.

4.9
(41)

Average rating 4.9 / 5. Vote count: 41