5 Best KitchenAid Toasters for Your Kitchen

Are you looking for the best toasters in the market? Well, KitchenAid has a full lineup of the most reliable toasters that can certainly impress you. They come in a wide variety including ovens, pop-ups, convection, digital, and more. 

These toasters can then be used to prepare toasted sliced bread, bagels, grilled cheese sandwiches, and more. They are also handy in reheating food or outright cook certain food items of your choice. This makes KitchenAid toasters a truly powerful, efficient, and dependable kitchen appliance in your kitchen. 

With this, we rounded up the best KitchenAid toasters with our group of experts to give you these five best options you should consider. Each one offers excellent value for money and is worth checking out. So, take a look at them now and pick the best one that would suit your kitchen needs!

Best KitchenAid Toasters Comparison & Rating

Want to Learn More?

Before you decide what KitchenAid toaster to buy, you might want to find out more about the best options available. This is to make sure that you will absolutely enjoy the KitchenAid toaster that you would get for your kitchen. Also, be sure to click the yellow buttons below to see their best deals on Amazon! With that, here are five of the best options that we found especially for you.

KitchenAid KMT4115SX Stainless Steel Toaster

KitchenAid KMT4115SX Stainless Steel Toaster, Brushed Stainless Steel
Specifications

Dimensions

11.5 x 12.5 x 8.3 inches

Color

Stainless Steel

Material

Stainless Steel

Weight

8 pounds

Rating: 97% Overall
97%
temperature Control
97%
performance
97%
capacity
96%
value for money
Pros
  • Comes with a smooth, polished stainless steel finish
  • Accommodates up to four toasters at the same time
  • Includes a cancel button to stop toast from burning
  • Features a toast shade control function to control how dark the toast will be
  • Comes with two separate pop-up levers to toast two bread slices at a time
  • Comes with a removable crumb tray
Cons
  • Sometimes, one side of the bread is a bit darker than the other in one of the slots but won’t generally affect the taste of bread.
  • The front top and back get very hot so it is not ideal to be placed under a cabinet or near any walls.
  • The loud notification beep is a bit loud which could be an issue for others.
Verdict

This is a great toaster that does exactly as you expect. It can accommodate sliced bagels and bread with thicker slices. It has an impressive and efficient bagel button setting that completely toasts the bagels inside while leaving the exterior of the bread warm and chewy. It has very efficient temperature settings that let you toast bread in a matter of minutes with satisfying results. Nonetheless, it is advisable to be careful in using higher temperature settings as it can burn pieces of bread in thin slices.


KitchenAid KMT2115CU Toaster

KitchenAid KMT2115CU Toaster, Contour Silver
Specifications

Dimensions

7.3 x 11.3 x 8.3 inches

Color

Silver

Material

Stainless Steel

Weight

4 pounds

Rating: 95% Overall
95%
temperature Control
96%
performance
94%
capacity
96%
value for money
Pros
  • Features an all-metal construction for durability
  • Boasts a stylishly smooth stainless steel finish
  • Comes with a toast shade dial for controlling toast color
  • Includes a cancel button to interrupt the toasting process
  • Comes with a bagel button to accommodate the thicker bread
  • The crumb tray is reliable and removable.
Cons
  • Comes with a buzzing sound that can be a bit annoying
  • Can only process two slices of bread at a time
  • Higher temperature settings can easily burn thin slices of bread.
Verdict

This is a good toaster to have for those who live alone. It makes two toasts at the same time and you can control how toasted you want your bread, thanks to its numerous temperature controls. It works well with bagels. It toasts the cut side of the bagel with the inside heat coils while just warming the outside part of the bagel. It will work just the same with English muffins.  The toast will also come all the way out once it’s done, so you don’t risk touching the hot surface.


KitchenAid KMT4203FP Pro Line Series Automatic Toaster

KitchenAid KMT4203FP Pro Line Series Frosted Pearl White 4-Slice Automatic Toaster
Specifications

Dimensions

16 x 15 x 10.1 inches

Color

Frosted Pearl White

Material

Stainless Steel

Weight

18.2 pounds

Rating: 95% Overall
95%
temperature Control
94%
performance
97%
capacity
94%
value for money
Pros
  • Keeps the toast warm without burning it
  • Comes with an automatic lift and lower function
  • Can accommodate up to four pieces of sliced bread
  • Features a seven-shade setting for toast color
  • Includes a bagel function to accommodate the bread
  • Comes with a frozen function to toast frozen food
Cons
  • Features numerous buttons that could confuse new users
  • The four bread compartments are fairly small.
Verdict

This is a heavy-duty toaster with several interesting functions. It’s built to last a long time and is guaranteed to be useful for many years. When toasting normal-sized slices of bread, it’s fast and efficient. You also get a lot of control so that you can toast bagels to your desired shade and texture. You can even toast four pieces of bread, leave two for later, and find that they are still warm.


KitchenAid KMT5115BM 4 Slice Long Slot High-Lift Lever Toaster

KitchenAid KMT5115BM 4 Slice Long Slot High-Lift Lever Toaster, Black Matte
Specifications

Dimensions

16.4 x 18.5 x 13 inches

Color

Matte Black

Material

Stainless Steel

Weight

34.7 pounds

Rating: 92% Overall
93%
temperature Control
94%
performance
92%
capacity
90%
value for money
Pros
  • Comes with extra-long and extra-wide slots
  • The slots are self-centering for better toasting.
  • Features a high-lift lever for easier extraction of the toast
  • Comes with a defrost feature for frozen bread
  • Able to accommodate bagels for toasting
  • Includes a removable tray for catching crumbs
  • Comes with a compact body
Cons
  • Some parts are made of plastic but sturdy
  • Release button is a bit small
  • Confusing controls and lever
Verdict

This is actually a pretty standard toaster that is reliable and does the job. If all you want to do is toast two to four slices of bread, this toaster will not fail you. It can even toast other types of bread other than sliced bread. The size of the bread is not as big of an issue either. However, compared to the other controls of other models, this one has a lever and controls that could confuse new users due to the likeness of appearance. Nonetheless,  and generally, this is a good toaster that is equipped with the necessary and efficient features you need.


KitchenAid KMT2115ER Toaster with Manual High-Lift Lever

KitchenAid KMT2115ER Toaster with Manual High-Lift Lever, Empire Red
Specifications

Dimensions

7.3 x 11.3 x 8.3 inches

Color

Empire Red

Material

Stainless Steel

Weight

4 pounds

Rating: 90% Overall
90%
temperature Control
89%
performance
90%
capacity
90%
value for money
Pros
  • Comes with two slots that are extra-wide
  • Features a bagel function that can toast the sourdough bread
  • Includes a cancel button that helps prevent burnt toast
  • The all-metal construction ensures durability.
  • The cord can be stored underneath for neatness.
  • The crumb tray can be removed for cleaning.
Cons
  • Loud notification sound
  • Sensitive temperature controls
Verdict

This is a solid toaster that will give you some nice pieces of toast. The slots won’t give you much trouble even if you are trying to toast thick slices of bread. They can even accommodate bagels, though, you do have to press the right button first. You can be the one to decide how dark the shade of the toast will be, but it can require some trial and error. If things go wrong, you can always stop the toasting process midway.

KitchenAid Toaster Buyer's Guide

capacity

You need to consider how many pieces of toast you will normally be eating before buying a toaster. If you live alone, then a toaster that can accommodate one or two pieces at a time would be fine. If you are preparing breakfast for an entire family, getting a toaster that can do four or six at a time might be better.

toasting

Toasters should be able to brown the bread in a reasonably fast manner. It should only take a few seconds if you are using a pop-up toaster to toast sliced bread.  However, it shouldn’t do it too fast either because you could end up with burnt toast.

features

Temperature controls are ideal for larger toasters with higher capacity since it will help avoid burns. Pop-up toasters should also turn off automatically and eject the toast on their own. As for oven toasters, they should have two-directional heat sources and a metal tray.

cleaning

Toasters should be relatively easy to clean by removing burnt crumbs, stains, or toast residue. Oven toasters should be particularly easy to access since they offer enough room for you to reach into them. Every nook and cranny should be effortless to wipe with a damp cloth.

intuitive

 No one should have to struggle to use a toaster. This means that it should have straightforward functions that are easy to control. Ideally, they should also have temperature control features that allow you to precisely control how toasted your toast will be. They should also have enough space to fit bread slices of all sizes.

FAQs

Are toasters necessary to toast bread?

Bread can be toasted on anything that generates enough heat like a fire or a stove pan. However, toasters are more convenient and easier to toast with.

What else can I use over toasters for?

Reheating food, making hot sandwiches, and cooking certain types of packaged food items.

Oven toasters or pop-up toasters?

If you only need it for toasting sliced bread or bagels, then a pop-toaster would be fine. If you need more versatility, an oven toaster would be better.

Why is my toast always burnt?

You could have the temperature too high, setting the time too long, or the bread is too close to the source of the heat.

0
(0)

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0