5 Best Canned Pizza Sauce for your Kitchen

There’s no sense denying it; nothing can rival a homemade pizza sauce. Taking your time to peel the tomatoes and vegetables then preparing your sauce with love is a pleasant experience.

Sadly, it’s something that we cannot always do because of our busy daily schedules. I mean, we hardly find time to eat nowadays, let alone spend hours preparing a delicious meal.

Thankfully, canned food is to the rescue (again). This time, all you need is a canned pizza sauce, and you’re off to a fancy dinner, be it alone or with the family.

What are you waiting for? Prepare your Pizza Pans and preheat your Pizza Oven, it’s time to cook some dinner!

Canned Pizza Sauce Review Center

Want to learn more?

Now that you’ve seen our top 5 recommendations, we’ll give you more detail on each of them, including why we liked them. When you’re ready, click the yellow button to get the best price on Amazon!

#1 – Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce Product Image

Although delicious, the sauce is primarily made with corn oil that contains a significant amount of saturated fat, making it rank among the least healthy oils to consume. It would have been way better if they used Olive Oil instead. Moreover, it has not been officially stated as to whether or not the product is BPA free. A further annoying fact is the crunching resulting from the tomato seeds. Do not let all of that discourage you though, as the Don Pepino is still one of the best canned pizza sauce products thanks to its classic recipe and thick mixture.

What we like about it

What we adore about the Don Pepino Pizza Sauce is its classic recipe that has been there for years, and that transmits the wonders of the Italian Cookbook. Besides, the thick sauce can make any pizza more delicious, especially that it doesn’t contain any sugar, which can partially compensate for the corn oil usage.

Check Price on Amazon


#2 – Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef

Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef Product Image

The sauce is based on olive oil and mixed with different types of cheese – including Pecorino Romano cheese – which enriches it and makes it one of the greatest sauces. It is perfect for traditional, adult spiced and seasoned pizzas. It can also be used as an additional sauce and deepen the flavor. For this very reason, it became so popular and commonly used for home-made pizzas.

What we like about it

Besides the fact that this sauce has an excellent taste, we also dig how healthy it is, as it’s BPA-free and doesn’t contain any preservatives, gluten, and corn syrup. Also, nothing can rival the sweet taste if the Californian tomatoes in the Pastorelli Pizza Sauce and the enhanced taste thanks to the cheese. Keep in mind that the flavor can be a bit strong for kids, so make sure to think twice before getting this sauce for a family dinner. Maybe you needn’t get your Dinnerware Set after all.

Check Price on Amazon

#3 – Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce

Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce, No Sugar Added, 15 Ounce Can (Pack of 12)

No one can deny how good Muir Glen’s tomato products are. They have always been of high quality, irresistibly tasty and flavorful. The flavor has never been a problem, for although savory enough for me, it still is suitable for children. The company’s organic pizza sauce is no exception, being quite delicious. The sauce does not contain sugar, which may trigger in some people a sense of dissatisfaction, as the dominant tomato taste makes it not as sweet as they wish. It also tastes a bit of herb but nothing to complain about. I genuinely love this sauce, and I’d happily get my Baking Tools to prepare the dough for it any time of the week.

What we like about it

The tomato is cultivated in the United States and is organic, which makes for a smooth sauce. Besides, they don’t contain any sugar, and they come in a considerable size sufficient for a medium pizza. Some people found this sauce to be too spicy, but that wouldn’t be a problem for you if you’re, like me, someone who’s used to keeping the Salt and Pepper Grinder Set by his side all the time.

Check Price on Amazon


#4 – Rao’s Marinara Sauce

Rao's Marinara Sauce Product Image

Though it may be tiny, the difference between pizza sauce and marinara sauce is highly essential. Pizza sauce is only cooked once when putting on the pizza. This makes the sauce neatly penetrate through the whole pizza dough. Contrarily, marinara sauce is already cooked, which may result in a dissolving tomato flavor, as some pizza professionals assert.

The sauce is not exclusively pizza sauce. In fact, it can be used in other dishes, for example in dips and over Pasta. If you decide to go with this sauce, maybe you should keep your Pasta Makers next to your Baker’s Rack and Bakeware Set.

If you are not a fan of the heavy-tomato sauce, then this one is a good choice.

What we like about it

What we really dig about the Rao’s Marinara Sauce is its multiple potential uses along with the Enriched flavor and the Closeable jar in which it comes. If you’re someone who likes to try a lot of recipes, say from a French Cookbook or an Irish Cookbook, maybe you should get this sauce and try it in different dishes besides pizza.

Check Price on Amazon


What to Look for in a Canned Pizza Sauce?

There are multiple factors you need to mind when buying a canned pizza sauce.

Check the Added Sugar

Generally, canned sauces contain a highly significant amount of sugar. Foods such as pizza do not need a significant amount of sugar, and adding too much would make it undesirably too sweet, which is a treat reserved for dessert, right?

Look for Added Vegetables

Some companies add vegetables to their sauces, which can be a helpful and subtle way to make kids eat their green yummies without noticing. Considering how children usually hate vegetables, maybe it’s a good idea to look for a canned pizza sauce brand that offers added veggies in their products.

Determine What Kind of Pizza Your Prefer

Chicago style pizza (deep dish) and New York style (thin crust) are one of the most reputable canned pizza sauces, fiercely competing in the market. Their underlying difference resides in the crusts. While Chicago style pizza develops a bulky bready crust, it’s New York counterpart produces an extremely thin one. This results in two contradictory consequences: a successful Chicago style pizza that supports whichever sauce quantity, and a flaccid and soggy New York style pizza. We like pizza to be foldable, not mushy.

Try a Kid-Friendly Taste

Kids generally prefer pizzas with a mild and sweet taste. You can opt for kid-friendly sauce, one with a  lot of garlic and herbs, and align it with your liking if you have children that like pizza as much as you do.

Notice the Texture

Chunky sauces are undesirable and uncomfortable to eat. Make sure to opt for a pizza sauce that does not contain tomato or vegetable chunks.

Mind the Jars or Cans

Pizza sauces are available either in jars or cans. If you, also, are worried about BPA that tomato releases, you’d rather opt for a pot or a can that is BPA free.


Today, it’s really hard to take your time to prepare a meal, even if you wanted to. Fortunately, you can resort to canned food to take care of either the whole dish or a part of it, which is the case for canned pizza sauce. All of the above recommendations are delicious and can make it for a great meal, but keep in mind that the sauce is only a part of the puzzle, with the dough and your skills being the other parts. Go on, grab your Pizza Cutter and Pizza Peel, it’s pizza time!

Before we forget, be sure to check out Amazon Prime Pantry for convenient online grocery shopping!


All Recipes

The Takeout

The Kitchn