Alfredo sauce is one of the simplest (when made with store-bought jars of course), yet most delightful pasta dishes. Known originally as Fettuccine Alfredo, is a pasta dish from Italian origin (you can tell by the name) that’s made with fettuccine cheese tossed with parmesan and butter.
The signature sauce is obtained when the cheese melts, emulsifying the liquid into a rich sauce that coats the Pasta. Throughout the centuries, this dish has been popularized across many countries until it spread to the US.
This meal makes for a perfect dinner that’ll spice up your nights. And with this list that we’ve compiled while we tried every single one out there to get you the best of them, you can ensure that it will not disappoint. So, get your Pasta Makers, Pastry Cutters, and Pastry Scrapers, and follow us through this guide for the best alfredo sauce jar picks on the market.
Store-Bought Alfredo Sauce Review Center 2021
|#1 - Bertolli Alfredo Sauce||99%|
|#2 - Primal Kitchen No Dairy Alfredo Sauce 2 Pack||97%|
|#3 - Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce||95%|
|#4 - Rao's Homemade Roasted Garlic Alfredo Sauce||92%|
|#5 - Barilla Creamy Alfredo Pasta Sauce||89%|
Now that you’ve seen our top 5 recommendations, we’ll give you more detail on each of them, including why we liked them. When you’re ready, click the yellow button to get the best price on Amazon!
#1 – Bertolli Alfredo Sauce
The famous Bertolli brand is traditionally associated with refined taste and high quality. Moreover, it makes authentic products, particularly their alfredo sauce. The ingredients from which it is made include Romano cheese, fresh cream, and aged parmesan cheese. This delightful sauce will be your favorite go-to in those times where you need a quick dinner or snack.
The marvelous Bertolli Alfredo Sauce comes in a glass jar, which helps in keeping its’ freshness. Moreover, this container makes it easy to use. Additionally, it is quite easy to store. The brand is highly recognizable, so that red label will probably catch your eyes when you come across it in one of your shopping errands.
What we like about it
If you happen to be an aged cheese aficionado, then this a must-try brand, that once you try it, you can’t go back. This is because the creamy, thick texture will make for an exquisite gustatory experience that you’ll want to replicate from time to time.
This fresh sauce has the perfect traditional alfredo sauce taste, and the only problem it has is that it ends too soon!
What are you waiting for, get your Jar Opener!
#2 – Primal Kitchen No Dairy Alfredo Sauce 2 Pack
Who, among us, doesn’t love bacon? We all do, with varying degrees. And for the ones who particularly cherish our beloved dried meat, this sauce is a heavenly combination.
Basically, you get the best of both worlds: a delicious, rich sauce, and that marvelous bacon flavor, in one Food Storage Container! This is the best thing to make a meal with if you’re tired of the usual dishes and looking for a change, for it will spice up your day with a distinctive vibe. The glass jar is crucial, as usual, in keeping the ingredients fresh.
This sauce is exceptionally versatile, as is all alfredo sauces. In fact, you can utilize this particular variety to make a magnificent dish in a matter of minutes. Notably, it goes outstandingly with penne pasta and salad. But any meat and vegetable combination works really well too. I guess it’s time to get your Salad Spinner and Salad Dressing Shaker, huh?
What we like about it
The ingredients used in this sauce are of excellent quality, as is this brand. Moreover, it is incredibly easy to store as it fits easily in the fridge or Compact Refrigerator. In conclusion, no problems have been found with this product, for that anything with bacon is most likely of high-caliber!
#3 – Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce:
If you’re facing one of those times when you’re craving a cheesy pasta dish, but all the calories are making you question your desire, then worry no more, for this product exists to fulfill your particular need, carrying half the calories and a third of the fat that other products contain. Who said you cannot pursue your diet and enjoy delicious food at once? This sauce defies that logic and proves that you can indeed have the best of both worlds. In fact, it is a signature recipe. Thus the quality and the taste are indisputably on par with your expectations.
So, if your gustatory senses have been tingling immensely when we went over other alfredo sauces, but your conscience is not letting you have it because of health concerns, it has no excuse right now! You can enjoy your favorite pasta dish with peace of mind from now on.
#4 – Rao’s Homemade Roasted Garlic Alfredo Sauce
Rao’swell-known legendary New York restaurant, has its own take on this classic sauce.
If you are a fan, you might as well buy his product as it includes ingredients of the highest quality like fresh cream, thus it has that traditional flavor. This is also a great item to have on hand for the times when you’re too busy to go through a lengthy kitchen session.
Moreover, the dairy in the sauce goes well with broccoli and chicken in particular, and this is a perfect combo that can be put together rather quickly.
What we like about it
Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta Sauce lives up to the legacy of its’ maker, and it is surprisingly highly accessible, so you have no excuse to not try it.
#5 – Barilla Creamy Alfredo Pasta Sauce
Barilla is the name that most people associate with pasta. No matter the type, this versatile sauce will go well with it. It is an outstanding addition to your pantry, being a great measure to deal with situations where you need a meal ready in a short amount of time. More often than not, you encounter these particular cases, and not only you can make a quick meal with it, this sauce makes it delightful too!
This sauce is a milder choice than the staple Canned Tomatoes sauce, which is convenient when you want some change, especially since it is equally good, if not better! A marvelous addition to any party or gathering, it is made with authentic ingredients such as cream and Romano cheese. Moreover, the percentage of salt in this product is better relative to other ones in the market, and the thicker texture is a big plus.
What we like about it
If the store you’re shopping at has it, you’ll certainly notice it in the pasta aisle. The brand is super-recognizable, Barilla being a household name especially in Italy where it is number 1. So, if almost everybody trusts it, you can’t really go wrong with it!
Alfredo Sauce’s Buyer’s Guide
Here’s everything you need to know about choosing the perfect Alfredo Sauce!
The flavor and Texture Varieties
Traditional alfredo sauce brands such as Barilla and Bertolli provide products that are characterized by a classic flavor, one you would expect from the white gravy. If you’d rather add a stronger taste that complements meats better, you should opt for the McCormick Creamy Garlic Alfredo Sauce Mix instead. It’s preferable if you have both along with other varieties at hand to satisfy all your cravings.
Powder or Fresh Sauce
Both these options are suited for different situations, and to pick between you need to consider your particular case. Whether you prefer consuming fresh, non-preserved foods or you don’t care about that aspect and instead, you’re looking for something that you can store in the Chest Freezer for times of need because that desire for a creamy, cheesy meal can hit you at any given time.
As far as fresh alfredo sauces go, our equally favorite pair of them is the Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce and the Only Original Alfredo Sauce. Both of these brands employ fresh cream and cheeses in the making of their sauces. The only original one is packaged in a refrigerator tub so it can be used by the serving.
Let’s now look at powder canisters and packets. These packaging methods don’t necessitate the use of the fridge, which helps to keep it free at vital times, instead, is stored in the pantry. Moreover, they can be used at any given time, whenever you need them to make the most delicious sauce which is no different than a fresh one.
There are two options in this category that are almost impossible to pick the best of, so we advise you to try them for yourself and make your own opinion that corresponds to your unique taste, between the Knorr Classic Alfredo Sauce Mix and the McCormick Creamy Alfredo Sauce.
Whether you like to consume cleaner, organic food or you’re on a diet, we got you covered. We present the Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce and the Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce, in the hopes of satisfying your particular needs.
Picks That Work Best with Meats and Veggies:
If you’re a bacon enthusiast (everyone is really), then this one will completely excite you: The Prego Alfredo Sauce with Real Bacon! For that obvious reason, it is our first mention. Another great sauce, better suited for accompanying Canned Chicken and broccoli, or making a white pizza in your Pizza Oven, is the Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Sauce. With this one, you can really come up with your own combos when it comes to what you can add to, the only limit is your creativity!
Whatever the first pick you decide to go with, certainly a few of these choices are going to end up as staples in your kitchen. Especially for variety’s sake, as these aforementioned alfredo sauces come in largely different textures and flavors and are perfect for different occasions with different meals. And, of course, the one with bacon gets a special mention, for bacon is universally beloved.
The list we have compiled is an alfredo sauce guide that covers all of the spectrum that’s available on the market, while also providing a great variety that won’t be in conflict with your particular needs and taste.
As a matter of fact, you can opt for a fresh sauce that’ll provide a refreshingly natural flavor or the powder one which will last you a long while and be your loyal companion in times of need.
Additionally, if you are one to crave organic, natural products then we got you covered, as we included an option that goes well with this trend, which is an extremely healthy sauce that is much more diet-friendly.
So, whether you’re into thick sauces with rich flavor, or milder ones, authentic ones that contain that traditional flavor, or even bacon, you can’t go wrong with this list, just look for the one that suits your desires best, and we ensure you that’ll become a staple in your pantry! Don’t forget to fill a Beer Glass or Champagne Glass from your Bar Set for extra taste!